Breadcrumbs generation doesn't care parent page across multiple collections

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.

[mumincelal]

I am using the nested-docs plugin to create breadcrumbs. 4 different collections use nested-docs but when I select the parent page from one collection to another, the plugin doesn't create breadcrumbs correctly. It doesn't care parent page but if I select the parent page in the same collection then the plugin is successful to create breadcrumbs correctly.

Here is the setup:

nestedDocs({
collections: [Page.slug, Post.slug, EnBlog.slug, TrBlog.slug],
parentFieldSlug: 'parent',
breadcrumbsFieldSlug: 'breadcrumbs',
generateLabel: (_, page) => (page.name as string) || '',
generateURL: (pages) =>
pages.reduce((url, page) => ${url}/${page.slug}, '')
})

If I choose a parent from page collection to page collection, the plugin works correctly but If I choose a parent from post collection to page collection then the plugin can not generate parent page breadcrumbs.

The plugin needs to be worked across multiple collections.

[jacobsfletch]

Related conversation: https://discord.com/channels/967097582721572934/1115245109185880074

[jacobsfletch]

Hey @mumincelal since this is more of a feature request, I'm converted this issue to a discussion so we can keep the conversation going here!

[mumincelal]

Sure. Thank you

[mumincelal]

@jacobsfletch Is there any plan to implement it?

[ClementLaval]

@mumincelal I need the same thing 👍
I just made a proposal PR.