Update GettingStarted.md by Madejski · Pull Request #257 · LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Madejski · 2021-07-26T23:07:32Z

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links in the previous version which were pointing to the DP0 instructions

Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff

My only comment is that I think it would be good to have more explicit instruction about what needs to be changed in the notebook to make them work at NCSA

SimonKrughoff · 2021-08-06T21:04:29Z

+Now if you wish, you can import the notebooks developed for DP0 into your instance of Jupyter notebook at NCSA, by issuing a git clone 
+command ```git clone https://github.com/rubin-dp0/tutorial-notebooks.git``` and now you can use the DP0 - developed notebooks on the DC2 data. 
+You might wish to create a separate directory for the DP0-developed material, but this depends how you organize your Rubin notebooks. 
+It is important to note that the location of the data repository accessible from IDF (``` s3://butler-us-central1-dp01 ```) is not the same as that accessible from NCSA (``` /repo/dc2 ```). 


You also have to add an instrument argument to the butler constructor. I think I'd prefer to have the changes users need to make be very explicit i.e. instead of
repo = 's3://butler-us-central1-dp01'
you need to change to
repo = '/repo/dc2'
and
You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim'

@kadrlica - in response to your query about repos, I think that the repo difference is in my i, but we might as well add the other comment from Simon, namely You must provide an instrument in and data id e.g. 'instrument': 'LSSTCam-imSim' . Otherwise, I think it is ready for a merge. I like your grammar fixes!

kadrlica · 2021-09-03T12:50:48Z

@Madejski I was wondering if Simon's comments have been addressed so we can merge this PR.

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:26:35Z

-* [Help with getting set up to run and edit the Stack Club tutorial notebooks](https://github.com/LSSTScienceCollaborations/StackClub/blob/master/GettingStarted/GettingStarted.md#running-and-contributing-to-the-stack-club-notebooks)
+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 


I think it would be more correct to say "distinct from the Interim Data Facility on Google Cloud used for Data Preview 0 (DP0)."

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:27:35Z

+First, a preamble: The instructions below are for setting up the Rubin account, and connecting to the Rubin Data Facility at NCSA, 
+used for the Rubin Stack Club members. This is 
+distinct from the Rubin Data Facility used for the work of Data Preview 0 (DP0) delegates, which is at the Interim Data Facility (IDF). The 
+instructions for connecting to the Rubin Science Platform as a DP0 delegate, go to https://dp0-1.lsst.io/dp0-delegate-resources/index.html 


"For instructions for connecting" (or some other grammar correction)

kadrlica · 2021-07-27T12:31:00Z

+> You can get AnyConnect by pointing your browser at https://sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/ and selecting the `ncsa-vpn-default` option (this will only work if you have a java-compatible browser, like firefox esr version<=52). If you already have the AnyConnect client installed, open it up and enter `sslvpn.ncsa.illinois.edu/` in its connection window. (**NB:** Make sure to use the `ncsa-vpn-default` group; this may not be the default group selected)

-If you forget your password it can be reset following the instructions [here](https://developer.lsst.io/services/lsst-dev.html?highlight=reset#lsst-dev-password). If you have problems connecting to the NCSA services you can check their status and submit a help ticket [here](https://confluence.lsstcorp.org/display/DM/LSST+Service+Status+page).
+> You will need to setup two-factor authentication with DUO. To setup DUO, follow the instructions herehttps://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal. DUO can be configured for smartphone or table access (currently dumb phones are not supported). When AnyConnect asks for your "second password", it wants the 6-digit number in your Duo app. (This may need refreshing, each one can only be used once.) (**NB:** Use "NCSA as the identity provider", not your institution). 


https://duo.security.ncsa.illinois.edu/portal sends me to a webpage that requests me to login with kerberos.

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Update GettingStarted.md
8329dd7
Reverting to a version that is for getting started on NCSA, for Stack Club members who are not DP0 delegates - fixes the links pointing to the DP0 instructions

Madejski requested a review from kadrlica July 26, 2021 23:07

Madejski added 2 commits July 28, 2021 15:33

Update GettingStarted.md
df7e211

Update GettingStarted.md
1fca86f
Corected the method of authentication, via .pgpass rather than the yaml file

SimonKrughoff approved these changes Aug 6, 2021
View reviewed changes

kadrlica approved these changes Sep 3, 2021
View reviewed changes

Update GettingStarted.md
e08e9da

Uh oh!

Conversation

Madejski commented Jul 26, 2021

Uh oh!

SimonKrughoff left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

kadrlica commented Sep 3, 2021

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

3 participants

Uh oh!

Conversation

Madejski commented Jul 26, 2021

Uh oh!

SimonKrughoff left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

kadrlica commented Sep 3, 2021

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

3 participants

Uh oh!

Conversation

Madejski commented Jul 26, 2021

Uh oh!

SimonKrughoff left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

kadrlica commented Sep 3, 2021

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!