Add uWebSockets.js by MDA2AV · Pull Request #151 · MDA2AV/Http11Probe

MDA2AV · 2026-08-15T16:59:32Z

Two patterns account for most of it:

1. A generic 505 for anything the parser rejects. Valid HTTP/1.1 requests come back as 505 HTTP Version Not Supported with the body This server does not support HTTP/1.0. — including OPTIONS * HTTP/1.1 and a well-formed chunked request with a trailer:

POST / HTTP/1.1 · Transfer-Encoding: chunked · 5/hello/0/X-Checksum: abc
→ HTTP/1.1 505 HTTP Version Not Supported

This drives most of the Compliance and trailer-related Smuggling failures. The rejection itself is safe; the status code and message are misleading.

2. Duplicate Content-Length is accepted.SMUG-DUPLICATE-CL sends two conflicting lengths and gets a 200 using the first, leaving the remainder in the buffer — a smuggling vector, MUST-level:

Content-Length: 5 · Content-Length: 10 · body "helloworld"
→ 200, Content-Length: 5, body "hello"

Also worth flagging: COMP-HEAD-NO-BODY fails because uWS sends the body on a HEAD request (Content-Length: 2 and OK on the wire). Node's http suppresses it automatically; uWS does not, so every uWS app has to handle that itself.

These are uWS's own parser behaviours, not artifacts of the harness code in this PR — the 505 bodies are generated by uWS before any handler runs (<i>uWebSockets/20 Server</i>).

Verified locally

Image builds; all six endpoint contracts from the Add a Framework guide check out (GET /, POST / echo, HEAD /, OPTIONS /, POST /echo, /cookie); site build renders servers/uwebsockets.html bound to renderServerPage('uWebSockets.js').

Requested upstream in uNetworking/uWebSockets.js#1298, where the maintainer asked to add uWS here and fix standards behaviour rather than chase benchmark lists. Implements the four probe endpoints with the idiomatic uWS API: any() routes with the wildcard registered last, req.forEach for /echo, and onData/onAborted with a cork()ed reply for the POST body echo. Header and cookie handling mirror the Node and Express servers so the three stay comparable. uWS is not on the npm registry, so the dependency is pinned to the v20.69.0 release tarball — release tags carry prebuilt .node binaries, so no build step and no git in the image. The base image is node:22-trixie-slim rather than the usual node:22-slim because those binaries need glibc 2.38 or newer and bookworm ships 2.36; on bookworm the module fails to load at startup.

github-actions · 2026-08-15T17:02:26Z

Http11Probe — Compliance Comparison

Server	Score
uWebSockets.js	119/159	`███████████████░░░░░` 75%

✅ Baseline Passed

Compliance

Test	Expected	uWebSockets.js
`BASELINE`	2xx	✅`200`
`BARE-LF-REQUEST-LINE`	400 or close (pass), 2xx (warn)	❌`505`
`BARE-LF-HEADER`	400 or close (pass), 2xx (warn)	✅`400`
`OBS-FOLD`	400	✅`400`
`SP-BEFORE-COLON`	400	✅`400`
`MULTI-SP-REQUEST-LINE`	400 or 2xx; close/timeout = warn	❌`505`
`MISSING-HOST`	400	✅`400`
`INVALID-VERSION`	400/505, close, or timeout = warn	✅`505`
`EMPTY-HEADER-NAME`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CR-ONLY-LINE-ENDING`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`MISSING-TARGET`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`FRAGMENT-IN-TARGET`	400 or 2xx; 404 = warn	⚠️`200`
`HTTP09-REQUEST`	400/close/timeout	❌`505`
`INVALID-HEADER-NAME`	400 or close	✅`400`
`HEADER-NO-COLON`	400 or close	✅`400`
`DUPLICATE-HOST`	400	✅`400`
`CL-NON-NUMERIC`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CL-PLUS-SIGN`	400 or close	✅`400`
`WHITESPACE-BEFORE-HEADERS`	400 or close	✅`400`
`DUPLICATE-HOST-SAME`	400	✅`400`
`HOST-WITH-USERINFO`	400 or close	❌`200`
`HOST-WITH-PATH`	400 or close	❌`200`
`ASTERISK-WITH-GET`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`OPTIONS-STAR`	2xx or 405; close/timeout = warn	❌`505`
`UNKNOWN-TE-501`	400/501 or close	❌`TimedOut`
`LEADING-CRLF`	400 or 2xx; close/timeout = warn	⚠️`TimedOut`
`ABSOLUTE-FORM`	2xx preferred; 400/close/timeout = warn	❌`505`
`METHOD-CASE`	400/405/501 or 2xx; close/timeout = warn	⚠️`200`
`POST-CL-BODY`	2xx + echo	✅`200`
`POST-CL-ZERO`	2xx or close	✅`200`
`POST-NO-CL-NO-TE`	2xx or close	✅`200`
`POST-CL-UNDERSEND`	400/close/timeout	✅`TimedOut`
`CHUNKED-BODY`	2xx + echo	✅`200`
`CHUNKED-MULTI`	2xx + echo	✅`200`
`CHUNKED-EMPTY`	2xx or close	✅`200`
`CHUNKED-NO-FINAL`	400/close/timeout	✅`TimedOut`
`METHOD-CONNECT`	400/405/501 or close	❌`505`
`EXPECT-UNKNOWN`	417 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`GET-WITH-CL-BODY`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`CHUNKED-EXTENSION`	2xx preferred; 400 warns	⚠️`400`
`METHOD-TRACE`	405/501 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`HOST-EMPTY-VALUE`	400 or close	❌`200`
`REQUEST-LINE-TAB`	400 or 2xx; close/timeout = warn	❌`505`
`VERSION-MISSING-MINOR`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`VERSION-LEADING-ZEROS`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`VERSION-WHITESPACE`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`CONNECTION-CLOSE`	2xx + close	✅`200`
`HTTP10-DEFAULT-CLOSE`	2xx + close	❌`505`
`HTTP10-NO-HOST`	200 or 400	❌`505`
`HTTP12-VERSION`	200 or 505	⚠️`505`
`TRACE-WITH-BODY`	400/405 or 200	⚠️`200`
`CHUNKED-TRAILER-VALID`	2xx + echo	❌`505`
`CHUNKED-HEX-UPPERCASE`	2xx + echo	✅`200`
`RANGE-POST`	2xx (Range ignored)	✅`200`
`HEAD-NO-BODY`	2xx with no body	❌`200`
`UNKNOWN-METHOD`	501/405/400 or close	⚠️`200`
`DATE-HEADER`	2xx with Date header	✅`200`
`DATE-FORMAT`	IMF-fixdate format	✅`200`
`NO-1XX-HTTP10`	non-1xx response	✅`505`
`OPTIONS-ALLOW`	2xx with Allow header, or 405	⚠️`200`
`CONTENT-TYPE`	2xx with Content-Type	✅`200`
`VERSION-CASE`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`LONG-URL-OK`	not 414; close/timeout = warn	✅`431`
`SPACE-IN-TARGET`	400, close, or timeout = warn	❌`505`
`DUPLICATE-CT`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`TRACE-SENSITIVE`	405/501, or 200 without Auth	✅`200`
`RANGE-INVALID`	200 or 416	✅`200`
`ACCEPT-NONSENSE`	406 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`POST-UNSUPPORTED-CT`	415 or 2xx	✅`200`

Smuggling

Test	Expected	uWebSockets.js
`CL-TE-BOTH`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`DUPLICATE-CL`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CL-LEADING-ZEROS`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`TE-XCHUNKED`	400/501 or close	✅`400`
`TE-TRAILING-SPACE`	400/501 or 2xx+close	✅`400`
`TE-SP-BEFORE-COLON`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CL-NEGATIVE`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CLTE-PIPELINE`	400 or close preferred; 2xx acceptable	✅`400`
`TECL-PIPELINE`	400 or close preferred; 2xx acceptable	✅`400`
`CL-TRAILING-SPACE`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`TE-DOUBLE-CHUNKED`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`CL-EXTRA-LEADING-SP`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`TE-CASE-MISMATCH`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`CL-COMMA-DIFFERENT`	400 or close	✅`400`
`TE-NOT-FINAL-CHUNKED`	400 or close	❌`200`
`TE-HTTP10`	400 or close	❌`505`
`CHUNK-BARE-SEMICOLON`	400 or close	✅`TimedOut`
`CHUNK-EXT-INVALID-TOKEN`	400 or close	✅`400`
`BARE-CR-HEADER-VALUE`	400 or close	✅`TimedOut`
`CL-OCTAL`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-UNDERSCORE`	400 or close	✅`400`
`TE-EMPTY-VALUE`	400 or close	❌`200`
`TE-LEADING-COMMA`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`TE-DUPLICATE-HEADERS`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-HEX-PREFIX`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-SIZE-PLUS`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-SIZE-TRAILING-OWS`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CL-HEX-PREFIX`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CL-INTERNAL-SPACE`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-LEADING-SP`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CHUNK-MISSING-TRAILING-CRLF`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CHUNK-EXT-LF`	400 or 2xx	❌`TimedOut`
`CHUNK-SPILL`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CHUNK-LF-TERM`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`CHUNK-EXT-CTRL`	400 or close	✅`TimedOut`
`CHUNK-EXT-CR`	400 or close	✅`TimedOut`
`TE-VTAB`	400 or close	✅`400`
`TE-FORMFEED`	400 or close	✅`400`
`TE-NULL`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-LF-TRAILER`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`TE-IDENTITY`	400/501 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-NEGATIVE`	400 or close	✅`400`
`TRANSFER_ENCODING`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`CL-COMMA-SAME`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`CL-COMMA-TRIPLE`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`CHUNKED-WITH-PARAMS`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`EXPECT-100-CL`	100, 400 or 2xx	⚠️`100`
`TRAILER-CL`	400 or 2xx	❌`505`
`TRAILER-TE`	400 or 2xx	❌`505`
`TRAILER-HOST`	400 or 2xx	❌`505`
`TRAILER-AUTH`	400 or 2xx	❌`505`
`HEAD-CL-BODY`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`OPTIONS-CL-BODY`	400/405 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`CL-UNDERSCORE`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CL-NEGATIVE-ZERO`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CL-DOUBLE-ZERO`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`CL-LEADING-ZEROS-OCTAL`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`TE-OBS-FOLD`	400 or 2xx+close	✅`400`
`TE-TRAILING-COMMA`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`TE-TAB-BEFORE-VALUE`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`ABSOLUTE-URI-HOST-MISMATCH`	400 or 2xx	❌`505`
`MULTIPLE-HOST-COMMA`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CHUNK-BARE-CR-TERM`	400 or close	✅`TimedOut`
`TRAILER-CONTENT-TYPE`	400 or 2xx	❌`505`
`CLTE-CONN-CLOSE`	400, or 2xx + close	✅`400`
`TECL-CONN-CLOSE`	400, or 2xx + close	✅`400`
`CLTE-DESYNC`	400, or close	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET-CL-PLUS`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET-CL-NON-NUMERIC`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET-TE-OBS-FOLD`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-HEAD`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET-TE-TRAILING-SPACE`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET-TE-LEADING-COMMA`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`CLTE-SMUGGLED-GET-TE-CASE-MISMATCH`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`TE-DUPLICATE-HEADERS-SMUGGLED-GET`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`TECL-SMUGGLED-GET`	400, or close (no extra response)	✅`400`
`DUPLICATE-CL-SMUGGLED-GET`	400, or close (no extra response)	❌`200`
`GET-CL-PREFIX-DESYNC`	400/close preferred; extra response on step 2 = warn	⚠️`200`
`TECL-DESYNC`	400, or close	✅`400`
`CL0-BODY-POISON`	400/close preferred; poisoned follow-up = warn	⚠️`200`
`GET-CL-BODY-DESYNC`	400/close/pass-through; poisoned follow-up = warn	✅`200`
`OPTIONS-CL-BODY-DESYNC`	400/close/pass-through; poisoned follow-up = warn	✅`200`
`EXPECT-100-CL-DESYNC`	417/400/close preferred; poisoned follow-up = warn	⚠️`200`
`OPTIONS-TE-OBS-FOLD`	400, or 2xx + close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-INVALID-SIZE-DESYNC`	400, or close	✅`400`
`PIPELINE-SAFE`	2xx + 2xx	✅`200`

Malformed Input

Test	Expected	uWebSockets.js
`BINARY-GARBAGE`	400/close/timeout	❌`505`
`LONG-URL`	400/414/431 or close	✅`431`
`LONG-HEADER-VALUE`	400/431 or close	✅`431`
`MANY-HEADERS`	400/431 or close	✅`431`
`NUL-IN-URL`	400 or close	❌`505`
`CONTROL-CHARS-HEADER`	400 or close	✅`400`
`INCOMPLETE-REQUEST`	400/close/timeout	✅`TimedOut`
`EMPTY-REQUEST`	400/close/timeout	✅`TimedOut`
`LONG-HEADER-NAME`	400/431 or close	✅`431`
`LONG-METHOD`	400 or close	❌`431`
`NON-ASCII-HEADER-NAME`	400 or close	✅`400`
`NON-ASCII-URL`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CL-OVERFLOW`	400 or close	✅`400`
`WHITESPACE-ONLY-LINE`	400/close/timeout	❌`505`
`NUL-IN-HEADER-VALUE`	400 or close	✅`400`
`CHUNK-SIZE-OVERFLOW`	400 or close	✅`400`
`H2-PREFACE`	400/505/close/timeout	✅`505`
`CL-EMPTY`	400 or close	❌`200`
`CL-TAB-BEFORE-VALUE`	400 or 2xx	⚠️`200`
`URL-BACKSLASH`	400 or 2xx/404	⚠️`200`
`URL-OVERLONG-UTF8`	400 or close	❌`200`
`URL-PERCENT-NULL`	400 or 2xx/404	⚠️`200`
`URL-PERCENT-CRLF`	400 or 2xx/404	⚠️`200`
`CHUNK-EXT-64K`	400 or 2xx	✅`400`
`RANGE-OVERLAPPING`	200/206/400/416	⚠️`200`
`POST-CL-HUGE-NO-BODY`	400/413/close/timeout	✅`TimedOut`

Header Normalization

Test	Expected	uWebSockets.js
`UNDERSCORE-CL`	Reject/drop (pass), normalize (fail), preserve (warn)	⚠️`200`
`SP-BEFORE-COLON-CL`	Reject/drop (pass), normalize (fail), preserve (warn)	✅`400`
`TAB-IN-NAME`	Reject/drop (pass), normalize (fail), preserve (warn)	✅`400`
`CASE-TE`	Reject/drop (pass), normalize casing (fail), preserve (warn)	✅`400`
`UNDERSCORE-TE`	Reject/drop (pass), normalize (fail), preserve (warn)	⚠️`200`

_{Commit: b3b4c89}

Quality gate failed on Security Rating C for new code, from three major findings on the Dockerfile and one minor one. Add a generated package-lock.json and switch to npm ci, which pins the release tarball by sha512 integrity hash rather than trusting whatever the tag currently resolves to (docker:S8543, text:S8564). Pass --ignore-scripts; uWS declares no lifecycle scripts, so this costs nothing and closes the install-time execution path (docker:S6505). Run as the image's node user instead of root, matching Trillium, Effinitive, Horse and Swerver (docker:S6471) — port 8080 needs no privilege. .gitignore excluded every package-lock.json, which would have left the image building from an unpinned tarball in CI while working locally. Negate it for src/Servers so server locks are tracked; web/ is unaffected. Also Number.parseInt over the global (javascript:S7773). None of this touches HTTP behaviour: the suite scores 119/159 before and after, identical failure set.

sonarqubecloud · 2026-08-15T17:11:14Z

Quality Gate passed

Issues
0 New issues
0 Accepted issues

Measures
0 Security Hotspots
0.0% Coverage on New Code
0.0% Duplication on New Code

See analysis details on SonarQube Cloud

MDA2AV mentioned this pull request Aug 15, 2026
Add to Http11Probe uNetworking/uWebSockets.js#1298
Open

MDA2AV force-pushed the add-uwebsockets-js branch from b8b0cad to 77706a9Compare August 15, 2026 17:10

MDA2AV mentioned this pull request Aug 15, 2026
Add uWebSockets (C++) #152
Merged

MDA2AV closed this in #152 Aug 15, 2026

Navigation Menu

Add uWebSockets.js - #151

Add uWebSockets.js#151
MDA2AV wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
add-uwebsockets-js

MDA2AV commented Aug 15, 2026•
edited
Loading

Uh oh!

github-actionsBot commented Aug 15, 2026•
edited
Loading

Uh oh!

sonarqubecloudBot commented Aug 15, 2026

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

1 participant

Conversation

MDA2AV commented Aug 15, 2026• edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Verified locally

Uh oh!

github-actionsBot commented Aug 15, 2026• edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Http11Probe — Compliance Comparison

✅ Baseline Passed

Compliance

Smuggling

Malformed Input

Header Normalization

Uh oh!

sonarqubecloudBot commented Aug 15, 2026

Quality Gate passed

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

1 participant

MDA2AV commented Aug 15, 2026•
edited
Loading

github-actionsBot commented Aug 15, 2026•
edited
Loading