Project proposals - GSoC 2018

[samuelgoto]

Hey all, here is the list of the open proposals that I'm going through in this format with these guidelines.

Please add yours here (create a comment on this thread with a link to your design doc / prototype).

I'll use this thread here as an opportunity for everybody to: (a) know what others are working on, (b) get inspiration from other's proposals and (c) see what patterns of comment/feedback occurs.

Importantly, I'll also use this list to organize myself and make sure no proposal falls through the cracks. Hopefully, this also makes @redblobgames 's life easier too to help steer the designs in the right direction :)

This list is sorted arbitrarily. The status bit shows on whose court the ball is.

Student	Sample	Prototype	Status
@regalhotpocket	proposal	prototype	student
@kaushikgunda	proposal		student
@anisha1234	proposal	prototype	student
@Dragneel7	proposal	prototype	student
@simanw304	proposal		student
@vishakha-lalll	proposal	prototype	student
@sahibdhanjal	proposal		student
@SouravInsights	proposal	prototype	student
@kUSHAL0601	proposal	prototype	student
@a-y-u-s-h	proposal		student

Ping this thread if/when you are ready to share your design docs with me or need me to review them again.

[anishaswain]

@samuelgoto the correct link to my updated design doc is this. Please update the link mentioned in the thread.

[Dragneel7]

Hi @samuelgoto I have made another design doc for Chapter2 Logical agents. Please review it's narrative.
proposal : here
prototype : here
@redblobgames I had implemented the changes you suggested earlier.

[samuelgoto]

@samuelgoto the correct link to my updated design doc is this. Please update the link mentioned in the thread.

done

[samuelgoto]

Hi @samuelgoto I have made another design doc for Chapter2 Logical agents. Please review it's narrative.

Which one do you want me to look at (send link)? There is no point in me looking at more than one.

[Dragneel7]

The proposal is for another visualization, that is the design doc , please review that, it is more beneficial to get the doc right.

[samuelgoto]

I'm only reviewing one design doc at a time per student. Not fair with others if I spend more time in multiple proposals from a single student, but most importantly also makes me lost. Most importantly, most of the comments I made in your first doc are applicable to your second doc, so no point in me reviewing it again and giving you the exact same feedback.

Pick your favorite design doc for me to review and send me the link (I'm going to assume I'm currently looking/reviewing the one that I have assigned next to your name - lmk if you want that changed).

[anishaswain]

@samuelgoto You have added the design doc for the Wumpus World Problem but the prototype shows the 8 Queen problem. The design doc for the 8 queen problem is Here. If you will review only one doc at a time, then I request you to review the design doc for 8 queens first as I am more involved in that and have implemented it.

[samuelgoto]

@samuelgoto You have added the design doc for the Wumpus World Problem but the prototype shows the 8 Queen problem. The design doc for the 8 queen problem is Here.

Done. Changed your link to chapter 6.

If you will review only one doc at a time, then I request you to review the design doc for 8 queens first as I am more involved in that and have implemented it.

There really is no point in me reviewing more than one design doc before you are all able to produce a really good one: all of my comments are going to be repeated and you'd rather get a good review in one doc than a shallow review in two docs.

So, pick your favorite, and send it over. Focus on that.

Like I said earlier, quality, not quantity: optimize for substance rather than volume.

[vishakha-lall]

@samuelgoto I have made modifications to the design document. Please review it again. :) I got some suggestions about the design from @redblobgames and made modifications and noted alternatives too. Kindly provide feedback about that too.
Also, my Github username is @vishakha-lall Please modify that in the table.

[Dragneel7]

@samuelgoto I have updated my design doc, please review.

[simanw304]

@samuelgoto I updated my design doc, please kindly review it. Thanks! Here is the link .

[samuelgoto]

Done. I think I have reviewed most of your docs right now, lmk if I'm blocking you.