Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
[SPARK-13120] [test-maven] Shade protobuf-java - #10995
Conversation
tedyu
commented
Jan 30, 2016
Would like some feedback before creating a JIRA. Thanks |
SparkQA
commented
Jan 30, 2016
Test build #50447 has finished for PR 10995 at commit
|
zsxwing
commented
Feb 1, 2016
Since Hadoop doesn't shade |
tedyu
commented
Feb 1, 2016
This would still benefit Spark standalone and Spark on Mesos, right ? For Spark on YARN, status quo is maintained. |
zsxwing
commented
Feb 1, 2016
@tedyu could you create a JIRA and add it to the title? This change is worth to have a JIRA to track. Ping @srowen@JoshRosen to take a look. |
JoshRosen
commented
Feb 16, 2016
Can you give this a descriptive PR description rather than a link to some mailing list thread? |
tedyu
commented
May 6, 2016
@zsxwing@JoshRosen@srowen Thanks |
vanzin
commented
Aug 4, 2016
@zsxwing is right. Because Hadoop libraries don't shade protobuf, this will not help. You'd have to create custom Hadoop jars referencing the shaded protobuf classes, and that's a much bigger change. (Both standalone and mesos still need hadoop jars, btw.) |
Closesapache#10995Closesapache#13658Closesapache#14505Closesapache#14536Closesapache#12753Closesapache#14449Closesapache#12694Closesapache#12695Closesapache#14810
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/protobuf/wAqvtPLBsE8
PB2 and PB3 are wire compatible, but, protobuf-java is not compatible so dependency will be a problem.
Shading protobuf-java would provide better experience for downstream projects.
This PR shades com.google.protobuf:protobuf-java as org.spark-project.protobuf