Brace Highlighting Should Activate at more positions

[cloudRoutine]

I marked out the columns where brace matching activates and where it does not
o means it activates on the following col, x means it doesn't i.e.

(* ox xo *)
 let a1 = [ 0 .. 100 ]
(* oxx xox *)
 let a2 = [| 0 .. 100 |]
(* oxx xox *)
 let a3 = <@ 0 @>
(* oxxx xoxx *)
 let a4 = <@@ 0 @@>
(* ox xo *)
 let a6 = ( () )
(* oxx xox *)
 [<ReflectedDefinition>]
 let a7 = 70
(* ox xo *)
 let a8 = seq { yield() }
(* oxx xxo *)
 let (| A9 |) = ()

I think brace matching should activate on either side of the brace and at all positions inside of the brace for multi column braces

It doesn't activate at all for -

• (* *)
• begin end
• struct end
• class end
• interface end
• < > for generics

[ vs2017 rc2 with latest tools built from master ]

[vasily-kirichenko]

+500 for this.

[saul]

With my latest PR (#3313), we're returning the correct braces to Roslyn. However, Roslyn explicitly ignores them. See http://source.roslyn.io/#Microsoft.CodeAnalysis.EditorFeatures/Implementation/BraceMatching/BraceHighlightingViewTaggerProvider.cs,3ee09e525b0037c8

/// Given code like ()^() (where ^ is the caret position), returns the two pairs of
/// matching braces on the left and the right of the position. Note: a brace matching
/// pair is only returned if the position is on the left-side of hte start brace, or the
/// right side of end brace. So, for example, if you have (^()), then only the inner 
/// braces are returned as the position is not on the right-side of the outer braces.
/// 
/// This function also works for multi-character braces i.e. ([ ]) In this case,
/// the rule is that the position has to be on the left side of the start brace, or 
/// inside the start brace (but not at the end). So, ^([ ]) will return this
/// as a brace match, as will (^[ ]). But ([^ ]) will not.
/// 
/// The same goes for the braces on the the left of the caret. i.e.: ([ ])^
/// will return the braces on the left, as will ([ ]^). But ([ ^]) will not.

You need to raise the issue with Roslyn, as they explicitly do not allow what you're asking (I agree it's counterintuitive).