from_grpc fails with got an unexpected keyword argument 'retry'

[rodis]

A call to from_grpc fails with

Traceback (most recent call last):
 File "deploy.py", line 43, in <module>
 main()
 File "deploy.py", line 36, in main
 if op.done() == True:
 File "/home/rosariod/.virtualenv/automl/lib/python3.6/site-packages/google/api_core/operation.py", line 170, in done
 self._refresh_and_update(retry)
 File "/home/rosariod/.virtualenv/automl/lib/python3.6/site-packages/google/api_core/operation.py", line 157, in _refresh_and_update
 self._operation = self._refresh(retry=retry)
TypeError: _refresh_grpc() got an unexpected keyword argument 'retry'

It seems like it sets _refresh_grpc as self._refresh for the Operation object https://github.com/googleapis/python-api-core/blob/master/google/api_core/operation.py#L299 but when _refresh_and_update is called by done, it gets and passes down to _refresh_grpc a retry param https://github.com/googleapis/python-api-core/blob/master/google/api_core/operation.py#L157 that _refresh_grpc doesn't know how to handle https://github.com/googleapis/python-api-core/blob/master/google/api_core/operation.py#L251 causing the error above.

It might be that the retry param could be correctly handled when the Operation object is created by from_gapic because in that case self._refresh is set to operations_client.get_operation https://github.com/googleapis/python-api-core/blob/master/google/api_core/operation.py#L325 which might be aware of the retry param but doesn't seem to be the case for from_grpc and from_http_json.

[busunkim96]

Hi @rodis,

Thanks for filing an issue.

1. Which versions of google-api-core and google-cloud-automl are you using?
2. When did you first notice this behavior?
3. Can you show us a bit of the code you're using?

[rodis]

hi @busunkim96

1. versions
   google-api-core (1.22.4)
   google-cloud-automl (2.0.0)

2. I just started to use the google-api-core library and I run into the issue as I started to use the from_grpc function

3. little extract from my code

SCOPE = 'https://www.googleapis.com/auth/cloud-platform'
SERVICE_ENDPOINT = 'automl.googleapis.com'

def main():
 creds = service_account.Credentials.from_service_account_file(CREDS_FILE)
 scoped_credentials = creds.with_scopes([SCOPE])
 request = google_auth_transport_requests.Request()
 channel = google_auth_transport_grpc.secure_authorized_channel(
 scoped_credentials, request, SERVICE_ENDPOINT)
 stub = operations_pb2.OperationsStub(channel)
 op = from_grpc(
 operations_pb2.Operation(name=OPERATION),
 stub,
 Model
 )

 if op.done() == True:
 sys.exit(0)

[busunkim96]

Is there a specific reason you're constructing channels and operations manually? It's possible to use the client library to fetch operations:

https://github.com/googleapis/python-automl/blob/v2.0.0/samples/snippets/get_operation_status.py

def get_operation_status(operation_full_id):
 """Get operation status."""
 # [START automl_get_operation_status]
 from google.cloud import automl

 # TODO(developer): Uncomment and set the following variables
 # operation_full_id = \
 # "projects/[projectId]/locations/us-central1/operations/[operationId]"

 client = automl.AutoMlClient()
 # Get the latest state of a long-running operation.
 response = client._transport.operations_client.get_operation(
 operation_full_id
 )

 print("Name: {}".format(response.name))
 print("Operation details:")
 print(response)
 # [END automl_get_operation_status]

[rodis]

Hi @busunkim96, thanks for your reply.
Isn't that more or less what from_gapic does? https://github.com/googleapis/python-api-core/blob/master/google/api_core/operation.py#L326
I guess I could but It feels like client._transport.operations_client.get_operation exposes me to too many internal details of the AutoML library that I shouldn't know about. Wouldn't that make my script rely on an internal variable _transport with a bunch of other details that from_gapic is taking care of for me?

[busunkim96]

That's a fair point. client.transport used to be public and I'm not quite sure what prompted the change. I opened googleapis/gapic-generator-python#640

As for from_grpc, I'll take a closer look today and get back to you.

[rodis]

@busunkim96 Thank you.

[busunkim96]

Hi @rodis,

The next release of google-cloud-automl will have a public property transport (see change to library templates in googleapis/gapic-generator-python@13cddda). Please use the operations client via _transport for now and switch to transport once the release is made.

I think your assessment that _refresh_grpc() doesn't know what to do with refresh is correct. The problem was likely introduced with 14f1f34#diff-6e22f95d11fd4cc631b3f0f432433561.