Error elaborations should not be de-duped

[AnyhowStep]

TypeScript Version: 3.5.1

Search Terms:

• Error message different

Code

interface ExprData {
 mapper : () => unknown,
 blah : string,
}
interface Expr<DataT extends ExprData> {
 mapper : DataT["mapper"],
 blah : DataT["blah"],

 extra : number,
}

declare function where (
 callback : () => Expr<{
 mapper : () => boolean,
 blah : string,
 }>
) : void;

declare function getInvalidWhere () : Expr<{
 mapper : () => (boolean|null),
 blah : string,
}>;

/*
Type 'Expr<{ mapper: () => boolean | null; blah: string; }>' is not assignable to type 'Expr<{ mapper: () => boolean; blah: string; }>'.
 Type '{ mapper: () => boolean | null; blah: string; }' is not assignable to type '{ mapper: () => boolean; blah: string; }'.
 Types of property 'mapper' are incompatible.
 Type '() => boolean | null' is not assignable to type '() => boolean'.
 Type 'boolean | null' is not assignable to type 'boolean'.
 Type 'null' is not assignable to type 'boolean'.
*/
where(() => getInvalidWhere())
/*
 Expected: Same error as above,
 Actual:
 Type 'Expr<{ mapper: () => boolean | null; blah: string; }>' is not assignable to type
 'Expr<{ mapper: () => boolean; blah: string; }>'.
*/
where(() => getInvalidWhere())

Expected behavior:

• Both errors should have the same error message, if they're in the same file.
• Both errors should have the same error message, if they're in different files.

Actual behavior:

• Both errors have different error messages in the same file.
• Both errors have different error messages in different files.

Playground Link:

Playground

Related Issues:

[AnyhowStep]

In my particular case,

I write compile time tests and it just so happens I was testing two different files.

One was the HAVING clause. The other was the WHERE clause.

Both clauses expect a boolean expression. Not a boolean|null expression.

However, I noticed that adding the HAVING clause test changed the WHERE clause test results...

---

This is like the union-order-during-compile-time problem
The union order can change depending on which line/file is compiled first.
This affects my compile-time tests.

---

In this case, the error message can change depending on which line/file is encountered first.
This also affects my compile-time tests.

[AnyhowStep]

The union-order-during-compile-time problem
#32224

[sandersn]

So, duplicate of #32224 then?

[AnyhowStep]

Not a duplicate!

This second instance of the error omits lines that the first instance would have.

It isn't reordering types, it's completely omitting lines from the message.

The first instance of an error could have 5 lines and the second instance of the same error, produced in a different way, in a different file, could have just 2 lines.

Because the second instance is omitting the last 3 lines that should be there.

They should be there because the extra lines can help with figuring out errors. It makes no sense to omit lines from a completely unrelated repro of the same error.

---

It's just that it reminds me of the union order problem a little. (Output changes based on what line is encountered first) They're completely different, though.

[sandersn]

Oh, that's just the fact that we only issue elaborations once per file. This is an intentional choice for batch compilation. I'm not sure it makes sense for the language service, but it sounds like you are getting these errors from batch compilation.

Without elaboration deduplication, batch compiler output would be huge. Are you proposing issuing all elaborations for every error in batch compilation, or in the language service?

[AnyhowStep]

Not the language service, I suppose. I'm not actually familiar with the TS API.

I think I might be using the batch compilation.
I pass in every single file I'm compiling to rootNames of the createProgram function.

https://github.com/AnyhowStep/tsql/blob/master/test/compile-time/util.ts#L129

So, I guess I'm asking for a way to turn off error deduplication for batch compilation. I'm comparing each file's actual output (.d.ts and errors) with some expected output.

So, if errors are getting deduplicated, it'll cause my actual output to change randomly as I add more tests.

I added comments to a commit on my project, it shows which lines were removed because of a test I added,

AnyhowStep/tsql-mysql-5.7@67374c1

[AnyhowStep]

I tried to create one program per compile-time test file. It's super slow =(

Before, I had,

const program = createProgram({
 rootNames,
 options,
});
program.emit(/*snip*/);

It took 30s to run tests on 674 files.

Now, I have,

for (const rootName of rootNames) {
 const program = createProgram({
 rootNames : [rootName],
 options,
 });
 program.emit(/*snip*/);
}

And I've been waiting for minutes and it still hasn't completed.

Is there any way I can speed things up? =(