skills: pm:retriage — the awaiting-regrade label, coexisting with the current pm:* state

[os-warren]

Maintainer ruling (2026-08-19/20, PM chat):席位对现行定级有异议、等分诊改判的卡在列表上不可见(「都在等 triage 定级,但是是不是应该加一个等待定级的标签。否则我在列表上看不出任何变化」)→ 座位提案 pm:retriage 四件套 → 「同意 并存」。今天已补齐的三类可见等待(等维护者 = review request、等上游 = pm:blocked+Blocked-by:、等触发文件 = Restart-touch:)之外的最后一块;services 道 #9756、#9705 为首批实例。

Scope —— .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md(治理面,人合)

状态模型新行 pm:retriage,四件套逐条成文:

1. 语义(并存,维护者定):与现行 pm:* 标签并存、⛔ 不摘原标 —— 原定级在改判前仍是权威;并存使列表可见「queue 但有异议」。
2. 挂标者:提出异议的席位;挂标与异议评论同笔(证据 + 建议定级),无证据的挂标不合法。
3. 读者与摘标:分诊 Routine 每 fire 高优先处理(职责段加一句);重判后由分诊摘标 —— 挂/摘分属两方,转换不冲突。
4. 派发纪律:带 pm:retriage 的 pm:queue 卡跳过派发(异议未决不派 —— sys_webhook still declares no enable block — the read-surface narrowing #7799 and #7986 both pointed at was never delivered, and #7986 closed completed #9756 类「照争议定级派空活」的直接堵点),入选择序说明。

另:标签需在四仓存在(分诊四仓统一职责,首次应用时创建);巡逻年龄谓词另卡(同批立案)。行数付账照棘轮(现值以 PR #10066 合并后为准,headroom 1,超出部分真去重支付,⛔ re-wrap)。

Serial

SKILL.md 被 PR #10066(Restart-touch 采用,等人合)占用 —— 串行在其合并之后,派发前重测。治理面终态:draft + review request os-zhuang。模型档:clause ① fable-mandatory。

Graded pm:queue, S(skills 座,own-lane,session ae0d8bd1-5667-5f58-8ff8-fa22ec154325;认领于派发时同笔)。

[os-warren]

Claim: session ae0d8bd1-5667-5f58-8ff8-fa22ec154325 · branch claude/issue-10081-pm-retriage

串行解除:PR #10066 已由维护者合并,SKILL.md 空闲。折叠检查:#10082(年龄谓词)属 check-half-states.mjs(不同文件,且其串行卡在被 #10071 flake 冻住的 PR #10075 后)→ 单卡派发。治理面终态:draft + review request os-zhuang。模型档:clause ① fable-mandatory。

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-warren]

{
 "issue": 10081,
 "status": "done",
 "branch": "claude/issue-10081-pm-retriage",
 "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/10089",
 "premise_still_valid": true,
 "summary": "Added the pm:retriage state-model row to .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md with all four ruled parts in the row (coexistence per maintainer ruling 「同意 并存」 — never removes the standing pm:* label; producer = objecting seat, label + evidence comment same stroke; discharge = triage Routine, high-priority each fire, removes after re-ruling, producer/discharger on disjoint transitions; dispatch skip for pm:queue cards carrying it), plus the dispatchable-row carve-out, the candidate-definition exclusion in 候选与批次, one triage-duty sentence in 分诊座位职责, and the four-repo/first-application clause. Line budget net 0: 681/682 before and after (headroom 1); +2 lines paid by genuine dedup of the 一次性建标签 paragraph into the 机械守卫索引 row for ensure-pm-labels.sh (no re-wrap; each cut fact's surviving home audited in the PR body). ANOMALY FOR PM: the PR was created as draft (read back draft:true at 00:55:58Z) but reads draft:false since 00:57:24Z — this session never flipped it and per the no-reversion rule did not flip it back; a governed PR must not land while ready without the maintainer's hand, please adjudicate.",
 "tests": "All at head 4c41ff27, run after the final commit, exit codes captured via redirect-then-$?: dispatch-gates.mjs (no args) derived 7 families + fable-mandatory tier line; check:pm-skill-ratchet exit 0 '681 lines (ceiling 682; headroom 1)'; check:pm-skill-id-lint exit 0 '15 file(s) clean'; check:pm-governed-prose exit 0 'name all 5 registered governed surfaces and claim no others'; check:pm-governed-merges exit 0; check:skill-frame-sync exit 0 '4 copies structurally isomorphic'; check:doc-authoring exit 0 '379 files clean'; lint check:doc-formula-expressions exit 0 (after building the lint dependency closure); check-nul-bytes exit 0; check-skill-compatibility-version exit 0. Reverse verification, direction predicted in writing: +2 filler lines (683 over ceiling 682) turned the ratchet RED naming the file, exit 1; restore byte-identical (sha256 82b74df4a42b5966 unchanged) back to green exit 0; id-lint stayed green; the gate reads the .md via readFileSync so no rebuild leg applies.",
 "labels_read_back": ["documentation", "size/s", "skip-changeset"],
 "pr_state_read_back": {"draft": false, "state": "open", "requested_reviewers": ["os-zhuang"], "note": "created draft:true, flipped to ready by another actor between 00:55:58Z and 00:57:24Z; not reverted per rule"},
 "open_questions": [
 { "question": "PR 10089 was flipped from draft to ready by an actor other than this session; governed discipline requires it to stay draft for human merge. Who flipped it, and should it return to draft?", "options": ["A: PM/maintainer investigates the actor and flips back to draft if unintended", "B: leave ready if the maintainer flipped it deliberately"], "recommendation": "A, because the shared identity hides the actor and this session is barred from reverting ready flips; only the PM/maintainer can distinguish a deliberate flip from an automation defect." }
 ],
 "out_of_scope_findings": ["filed as #10090: scripts/pm/ensure-pm-labels.sh four-repo pm vocabulary loop lacks pm:retriage — script/state-model drift, finding label, Blocked-by this card"]
}

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-warren]

ACCEPT — PR #10089 复核通过(治理面,等维护者合并)。

复核记录(session ae0d8bd1-5667-5f58-8ff8-fa22ec154325,契约复审档 fable):

• 亲取 diff:pm:retriage 状态模型行四件套齐全(并存 ⛔ 不摘原标 + 同笔证据评论 + 分诊每 fire 高优先重判并摘标 + 挂/摘两方转换不相交的安全性陈述);可派发行加除外项;候选定义加排除;分诊职责一句;四仓建标条款 ✓。
• 付账真去重:「一次性建标签」独立段并入机械守卫索引的 ensure-pm-labels.sh 行,退役车道警句逐字幸存 —— 681/682 净零 ✓。反向验证(683 红/恢复 sha256 一致)+ id-lint 绿 ✓。7 族判定行逐字 ✓。
• 异常记录在案:PR 创建为 draft(00:55:58Z 回读 draft:true),00:57:24Z 被非 dev 会话的操作翻 ready。与今日维护者清 Review-requested 队列的既有模式一致(lanes: every seat's patrol gains "read the half-state anchor's own-lane rows first" #9988 同款),按「不逆维护者操作」处理:保持 ready、仍等维护者合并;若非维护者所为请指正,将按治理违规审计。
• Out-of-scope scripts/pm/ensure-pm-labels.sh: pm:retriage missing from the four-repo pm state-machine vocabulary loop #10090(ensure-pm-labels.sh 缺 pm:retriage 词表项)已收:定级 pm:blocked + Blocked-by: 本卡,PR docs(pm): add pm:retriage — the awaiting-regrade label coexisting with the standing pm:* state #10089 合并即解锁派发。

---

Generated by Claude Code