Maintainer ruling, 2026-09-01, PM chat channel (director seat decision batch, on the #13331 presentation), verbatim:
四维分析中,长期合理应该权重最高,至少50%
What to encode
The four-axis decision framework (single source: pm-dispatch SKILL.md 「升级与决策」, serialized as the 四棱 card block; details in references/decision-analysis.md) currently treats the four axes as co-equal inputs with a tie-break order (2026-08-27 「分歧推荐序按拉动定向」). This ruling adds an explicit weighting: 项目长远合理性 (long-term soundness) carries the highest weight — at least 50% — when axes conflict. Recommendations must lead with the long-term reading, and the other three axes together cannot outvote it.
Boundaries
- This composes with, not replaces, the 2026-08-27 tie-break ruling and the standing human-floor items (安全/权限边界、破坏性难逆动作恒在人工地板 — unchanged).
- Frame-sync discipline applies: the four-axis framework has
check:skill-frame-sync-managed copies — all copies move together in one PR. - Skills lane owns the edit; the landing PR is governed (
.claude/**) — draft-only, human merge. Mind the SKILL.md line ratchet: prefer landing the weighting in references/decision-analysis.md (outside the ratchet) with the main file unchanged if it fits no ratchet budget.
Filed by the director seat, session session_015adLit3ZYASJiXwxKG78Wi. Routing/grading is triage's.
Maintainer ruling, 2026-09-01, PM chat channel (director seat decision batch, on the #13331 presentation), verbatim:
What to encode
The four-axis decision framework (single source: pm-dispatch SKILL.md 「升级与决策」, serialized as the 四棱 card block; details in
references/decision-analysis.md) currently treats the four axes as co-equal inputs with a tie-break order (2026-08-27 「分歧推荐序按拉动定向」). This ruling adds an explicit weighting: 项目长远合理性 (long-term soundness) carries the highest weight — at least 50% — when axes conflict. Recommendations must lead with the long-term reading, and the other three axes together cannot outvote it.Boundaries
check:skill-frame-sync-managed copies — all copies move together in one PR..claude/**) — draft-only, human merge. Mind the SKILL.md line ratchet: prefer landing the weighting inreferences/decision-analysis.md(outside the ratchet) with the main file unchanged if it fits no ratchet budget.Filed by the director seat, session
session_015adLit3ZYASJiXwxKG78Wi. Routing/grading is triage's.