Decode minikeys (like Casascius coin ones) - #141
Conversation
| minikey = minikey.encode('ascii') | ||
| length = len(minikey) | ||
| if length not in [22, 30]: | ||
| raise InvalidMinikeyError('Minikey length %d is not 22 or 30' % length) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I suggest using str("length is {} yo").format(length) instead of using the % operator.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Would you please explain why?
- % is not deprecated, and I find it even more readable
- % is used throughout the whole project
- for this use case the extra power of format provides no benefit as far as I can see
petertodd
commented
Jul 21, 2017
I think the minikey functionality should be in a different file than base58. Also, it doesn't make sense to decode minikeys to base58 - minikey decoding should be done to/from raw private keys. |
juestr
commented
Jul 21, 2017
Right, I was blinded by my use case. Btw there is no way to create a minikey from a raw key, it's one way only. I am going to extract everything to a minikey.py when I find time. |
petertodd
commented
Jul 23, 2017
Ah right, I should have realized a minikey is obviously a one-way transformation. Note that you also may consider just making this functionality a separate Python library - it might even be easier for people to find that way given that they may not be expecting to find such an old standard in a newer library. |
juestr
commented
Jul 30, 2017
It's just a few lines of code so I moved it to minikey.py and fixed the return type. If you don't want it in here at all that's fine for me too. Btw, the magic constructor of CBitcoinSecret confused me quite a bit. |
This adds decode_minikey to
base58.pyminikey.py. It checks for format and checksum errors.There are some test cases and an example cli tool: