Tracking issue for std::ptr::NonNull::cast

[SimonSapin]

ptr::NonNull<T> is similar to *mut T. Its cast method added in #47631 is similar to raw pointer casting with the as operator.

impl<T: ?Sized> NonNull<T> {
 pub fn cast<U>(self) -> NonNull<U> {
 unsafe {
 NonNull::new_unchecked(self.as_ptr() as *mut U)
 }
 }
}

Note that T is ?Sized but U is not (or we’d get a E0606 "vtable kinds may not match" error on as)

[joshlf]

Would it be possible to add a cast_unsized or similar method that converts into a fat pointer? This is probably less urgent - the necessity of cast comes from the fact that NonNull should have feature parity with *mut, and *mut has as - but it's probably worth at least discussing.

[SimonSapin]

How would that work? How does this method you pick a vtable or a slice length? The only way I know in safe Rust (other than ad-hoc APIs like String::into_boxed_str) of creating fat pointers is from thin ones through CoerceUnsized, which NonNull already supports:

#![feature(box_into_raw_non_null)]
use std::ptr::NonNull;

fn main() {
 // Creating thin pointers
 let a: NonNull<[u8; 10]> = Box::into_raw_non_null(Box::new([42; 10]));
 let b: NonNull<String> = Box::into_raw_non_null(Box::new(String::new()));

 // Coercing to fat pointers to dynamically-sized types
 let _a: NonNull<[u8]> = a;
 let _b: NonNull<std::fmt::Display> = b;
}

[joshlf]

I suppose I was thinking particularly about statically typed but dynamically sized fat pointers (e.g., to slices). I'm not sure how you'd answer the question about vtables. So, concretely, converting between, e.g., NonNull<[u32]> and NonNull<[u8]>, where the length field can just be maintained because they're both the same number of bytes (or multiplied by four? are fat pointer length fields byte size or element count?).

[SimonSapin]

Turns out you can cast a raw slice to another. This leaves the length unchanged regardless of the item type, which is often wrong. For example, this compiles and prints random (stack?) memory.

fn main() {
 let b = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5];
 let ptr = cast_slice::<u8, u64>(&b);
 for x in unsafe { &*ptr } {
 println!("{:016x}", x)
 }
}

fn cast_slice<T, U>(s: *const [T]) -> *const [U] {
 s as _
}

However that’s the case where the types on both sides of as are known to be raw slices. In the fully-generic ?Sized case the compiler doesn’t know what code to emit.

[joshlf]

Does that also work for structs with the last field as an unsized slice? (On my phone; can't test)

…

On Jan 22, 2018 1:39 AM, "Simon Sapin" ***@***.***> wrote: Turns out you can cast a raw slice to another. This leaves the length unchanged regardless of the item type, which is often wrong. For example, this compiles and prints random (stack?) memory. fn main() { let b = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]; let ptr = cast_slice::<u8, u64>(&b); for x in unsafe { &*ptr } { println!("{:016x}", x) } } fn cast_slice<T, U>(s: *const [T]) -> *const [U] { s as _ } However that’s the case where the types on both sides of as are known to be raw slices. In the fully-generic ?Sized case the compiler doesn’t know what code to emit. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#47653 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AA_2L_Rj579HpWdWeA2g0Hykoi51veOeks5tNFdKgaJpZM4RmTjN> .

[SimonSapin]

This compiles, however wrong it may be:

fn main() {
 struct Foo(u8, [u8]);
 struct Bar(String, [u64]);
 let ptr: *const Foo = unimplemented!();
 ptr as *const Bar;
}

But this is still slice to slice. If trait objects are involved, they need to be the same trait.

At least that’s the current implementation of as. I don’t have a strong opinion on how it should be.

[joshlf]

OK, probably worth it to just stick with cast for the time being and only address this if it becomes an issue for someone.

[SimonSapin]

This one-line method landed in Nightly on 2018-02-07. If stabilized in the current 1.26 cycle, it will reach Stable on 2018-05-11 after four months. @aturon, is this enough baking time to start FCP?

[SimonSapin]

#49669 adds a Void extern type (probably to be renamed) and uses it with NonNull. I’ve found myself trying to use this method to try to cast to NonNull<Void>, which doesn’t work because cast requires the destination type to be Sized. We can’t fully generalize to ?Sized because the method wouldn’t know how to make up a vtable pointer or slice length. It’s unfortunate that today’s type system can’t precisely express the actual requirement of a pointer being thin, but I think we can live with it. #49669 ends up adding a specific NonNull::as_void method.

TR;DR: Despite limitations I think we should stabilize this as-is.

@rfcbot fcp merge

[rfcbot]

Team member @SimonSapin has proposed to merge this. The next step is review by the rest of the tagged teams:

• @Kimundi
• @SimonSapin
• @alexcrichton
• @aturon
• @dtolnay
• @sfackler
• @withoutboats

No concerns currently listed.

Once a majority of reviewers approve (and none object), this will enter its final comment period. If you spot a major issue that hasn't been raised at any point in this process, please speak up!

See this document for info about what commands tagged team members can give me.