Skip to content

C_87: note the depth-of-inertia route to 770.644 as the nearest visible improvement - #152

Open
Chessing234 wants to merge 1 commit into
teorth:mainfrom
Chessing234:feat/87a-depth-comment
Open

C_87: note the depth-of-inertia route to 770.644 as the nearest visible improvement#152
Chessing234 wants to merge 1 commit into
teorth:mainfrom
Chessing234:feat/87a-depth-comment

Conversation

@Chessing234

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

The follow-up you suggested when merging #151: a line in "Additional comments and links" for [HMR2019, §3.3.4].

The record row cuts by $\tau_{\mathfrak{p}_{13}}^2$ because Proposition 1.8(iii) only gives depth at least two. §3.3.4 says that if the depth were greater than two, cutting by $\tau_{\mathfrak{p}_{13}}$ itself would give Golod–Shafarevich polynomial at most $1 - 9t + 20t^2 + t^3$, which still has a root in $(0,1)$ — so the same degree-12 field would have an infinite 2-Hilbert class field tower with no ramification at 13 at all, and the record would fall to $\mathrm{rd}_{\mathrm{K}} < 770.644$.

Quoted verbatim from the preprint:

In the example above, a hope would be that $\tau_{p_{13}}$ has depth greater than two in $G_S$. In that case we could cut by the relation $\tau_{p_{13}}$ and the corresponding Golod-Shafarevich polynomial would be at most $1 - 9t + 20t^2 + t^3$ which has a root in $(0,1)$. One would then have that $K$ has infinite 2-Hilbert Class Field Tower and the totally real root discriminant record would be $< 770.644$. We do not see how to check the depth of $\tau_{p_{13}}$ in $G_S$. See also the beginning of §5.

I added the pointer to §5.1, since that is where the obstruction is stated in general — Question 5.1 asks how deep the generator of tame inertia at a single prime coprime to $p$ can be when $G_S$ is infinite. As you said, this is a hope rather than a bound, so no table row and no README change: the bullet says explicitly that nothing above it changes.

Rendering: the bullet is inline math only, so underscores are escaped and the one literal brace pair is written \\{ \\}; there are no pipes in it, and the two tables still have four | per row.

Prepared with AI assistance; the §3.3.4 and §5.1 text was read from the arXiv PDF via pdftotext and the quotation above is transcribed from it.

Sign up for freeto join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant

@Chessing234