Automate Challenges jar compilation for Plugwright E2E tests and enforce Java 21

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.

[Drownek]

What does this PR do?

• Automates JAR building for E2E tests: Replaces the need for developers to manually run mvnw package before running plugwrightTest. The newly introduced buildChallenges Gradle task automatically runs the Maven wrapper to build the Challenges.jar dynamically as a test dependency.
• Java Toolchains Integration: Replaces manual Java Toolchain resolution with a proper, global java { toolchain { ... } } setup. Plugwright gracefully inherits this out-of-the-box, removing boilerplate code.
• Enforces Java 21+: Ensures the Maven build explicitly requires Java 21+ (via Maven Enforcer), failing early with a clear message if an older JDK is detected in the environment.
• Cleans up build.gradle.kts: Leverages idiomatic Gradle fileTree APIs for resolving the output .jar instead of verbose manual file traversal, making the build script significantly more readable.

How to test

Simply run ./gradlew plugwrightTest (or gradlew.bat plugwrightTest on Windows) inside the e2e directory. The project will seamlessly compile the Maven artifact and boot the Paper server for E2E testing without any manual prerequisites.

[mrfloris]

build.gradle.kts executes ./mvnw, but the PR adds mvnw with Git mode 100644, not 100755. E2E testing will fail with Permission denied on Unix systems and GitHub’s Ubuntu runner.

buildChallenges declares build/Challenges.jar as an output but declares no source, resource, or pom.xml inputs. Once that JAR exists, Gradle may mark the task UP-TO-DATE even after plugin code changes. This undermines the entire purpose of the feature. Declare the Maven project files as inputs or deliberately make the task always run.

The workflow still explicitly runs Maven, then plugwrightTest invokes buildChallenges, which runs Maven again: e2e.yml.

Existing target JARs can break local testing. fileTree(...).singleFile fails if target/ contains multiple matching JARs, which can happen after changing the project version without running clean.

The Maven enforcer accepts Java 21 or newer, but the Gradle toolchain requests exactly Java 21. There is no toolchain download resolver configured, so developers who only have Java 25/26 can receive “no matching Java installation” despite satisfying the stated requirement.

Verdict though; sensible feature, and i dont see anything dodgy with it. So once a human dev has made some logical changes i think this could be considered by tasty.

[Drownek]

Thanks for the review, good catches. Pushed a fix: mvnw is executable again, the Gradle task has its inputs declared, and clean is back in the Maven command.

On the Java version conflict: I changed the Gradle toolchain logic so it only requests Java 21 if the daemon's on <21. So devs on 17 still get it working out of the box, and reviewers on 22+ don't hit a strict lock. Also cut the redundant Maven step in e2e.yml.

Tested on 22 and 17, both fine.

[tastybento]

Thanks for this, and thanks @mrfloris for the first pass — those were good catches.

Context for anyone reading: I'm using Challenges as a vehicle to test plugwright. That's still a new approach and I'm waiting to see how it gets maintained, so I'm deliberately conservative about how much of the repo gets restructured around it. But the direction here is sensible and I'd like to take it.

I checked the branch out and actually ran it on macOS (Apple Silicon, Homebrew JDKs) rather than just reading the diff. Confirming the fixes hold up:

Check	Result
mvnw file mode	100755 — fixed
mvnw content	byte-identical to upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.2
mvnw.cmd content	identical to upstream modulo line endings (LF — but e2e/gradlew.bat is already LF in this repo, so pre-existing, not yours)
.mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar	byte-identical to the official maven-wrapper-3.3.2.jar on Maven Central (sha256 3d8f20ce…39c7a8)
./gradlew buildChallenges on JDK 21	builds, copies the right jar to e2e/build/Challenges.jar
same from a JDK 17 daemon	resolved a local Java 21 toolchain and built
re-run with no change	UP-TO-DATE
edit a .java, re-run	rebuilds
edit locales/en-US.yml, re-run	rebuilds
.singleFile vs original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar in target/	correctly picks the shaded jar

So the exec bit and the bogus up-to-date checking are genuinely fixed, not just claimed fixed. The redundant Maven step is gone from e2e.yml. The enforcer is harmless — every workflow already runs JDK 21 and <release>21</release> already fails on older JDKs, so it's purely a nicer error message, which is a fine small win.

Two things I'd like before I merge, both inline below:

1. Regenerate the wrapper scripts-only, to drop the committed binary.
2. Lose the clean — it's doing a lot of work just to keep .singleFile happy.

The rest of the inline comments are optional polish, take them or leave them.

---

Unrelated pre-existing issue I found while testing, flagging so nobody chases it as a regression here:./gradlew in e2e/ won't start at all on a machine whose default JDK is 25 — Gradle 8.10 doesn't understand that version and you get a bare * What went wrong: 25.0.1 with no further explanation. This reproduces on unmodified develop, so it is not caused by this PR. @mrfloris I suspect that's the macOS problem you hit. Bumping e2e/gradle/wrapper/gradle-wrapper.properties to Gradle 9.x fixes it — happy to take that as a separate follow-up.

I wasn't able to complete a full plugwrightTest run locally: port 25565 was occupied by another server on my machine, so Paper couldn't bind. That's my environment, not the PR.

[tastybento]

Could you regenerate this scripts-only?

mvn wrapper:wrapper -Dtype=only-script -Dmaven=3.9.12

That drops .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar entirely — mvnw becomes a self-contained script that fetches the distribution itself. Same behaviour, but I'd rather not carry a 63KB binary in the repo that has to be re-vetted by hand every time it's bumped. (I checked this one and it's clean — byte-identical to Maven Central — but that's a check someone has to remember to repeat.)

It also gets us off 3.9.6, which is from January 2024. 3.9.12 is what I have locally.

While you're in here: distributionSha256Sum is worth setting too, so the downloaded Maven distribution is verified rather than trusted.

[tastybento]

The clean is here only to stop .singleFile below choking on stale jars, and it's an expensive way to buy that. Every source change now forces a full recompile of the whole addon, and it wipes target/ — including surefire-reports and any jar someone has built to drop on a live server for manual testing.

Making the resolution robust instead means you don't need clean at all — see my comment on the doLast block.

[tastybento]

.singleFile is the thing forcing clean up on line 56. Picking the newest match is just as correct after a package and removes that constraint:

val builtJar = fileTree("../target") {
include("Challenges-*.jar")
exclude("*sources*", "*javadoc*")
}.files.maxByOrNull { it.lastModified() }
?:throwGradleException("No Challenges jar produced in ../target")

With that, line 56 can go back to -q package -DskipTests and the dev loop stays incremental.

(For what it's worth, I verified the current filter does correctly skip original-Challenges-*.jar and -sources.jar — original-… doesn't match the Challenges-* include. So this is about the clean, not about the filter being wrong.)

[tastybento]

Minor completeness point: .mvn/, mvnw and mvnw.cmd aren't inputs, so bumping the Maven version wouldn't retrigger the build. Cheap to add:

inputs.dir(file("../.mvn"))
inputs.file(file("../mvnw"))

Not a blocker — the src + pom.xml inputs are the ones that matter day to day, and I confirmed those work.

[tastybento]

Optional: javaLauncherProvider.get() here resolves the toolchain at configuration time, which forces the lookup (and potentially a provision) whenever the task is realised, even on a no-op run. Moving it into doFirst { environment("JAVA_HOME", …) } keeps it lazy and is friendlier to the configuration cache if this build ever turns that on.

Separately, the else branch overriding JAVA_HOME with java.home is a no-op in the normal case (Exec inherits the environment) but does override a JAVA_HOME the developer set deliberately when the daemon JVM was chosen via org.gradle.java.home. Narrow edge case, just noting it.

[tastybento]

This narrows @mrfloris's toolchain point nicely, but doesn't fully close it: a developer on Java 17 with no JDK 21 installed still gets "no matching toolchains found" and no way to recover automatically. Gradle can provision one if you add the foojay resolver to e2e/settings.gradle.kts:

plugins {
id("org.gradle.toolchains.foojay-resolver-convention") version "0.8.0"
}

Optional, but it's one line and it makes the "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" promise in the PR description actually true on a clean machine.

(On my Mac Gradle did find the Homebrew JDK 21 from a 17 daemon, so this only bites people who genuinely don't have a 21 anywhere.)

[tastybento]

Tiny thing: [21,) duplicates <java.version>21</java.version> up at line 42, so this silently goes stale when the project bumps. [${java.version},) keeps them in sync.

[tastybento]

Pushed a commit to this branch directly (be00869) rather than leaving the Gradle thing as a vague follow-up — it was blocking the very workflow this PR adds, so it belongs here.

What it does: bumps the e2e/ Gradle wrapper 8.10 → 9.7.0. Gradle 8.10 can't start on a JDK it doesn't recognise, so on any machine whose default JDK is 25, every ./gradlew in e2e/ died before even evaluating the build script, with nothing but:

* What went wrong:
25.0.1

To be clear @Drownek, this was not your bug — it reproduces on unmodified develop. But "just run ./gradlew plugwrightTest" is the promise of this PR, and it wasn't true for anyone on a current JDK. @mrfloris I'm fairly confident this is the macOS problem you ran into.

Three parts:

• Wrapper regenerated using the documented two-passwrapper run, so gradle-wrapper.jar is genuinely the 9.7.0 one. (First pass under 8.10 only rewrites the properties and leaves an 8.10 jar behind — easy trap.) Its SHA-256 is 7a9ce74cff467ca1bf60a4fcd9f05185acceda4d0f382434d393e17864262c5d, matching the checksum Gradle publishes for gradle-9.7.0-wrapper.jar.
• distributionSha256Sum pinned, so the downloaded distribution is verified rather than trusted. Same reasoning as my comment about distributionSha256Sum on the Maven wrapper.
• buildChallenges moved from by tasks.registering(Exec::class) to tasks.register<Exec>("buildChallenges"). Gradle 9.6 deprecated the delegate form; without this the bump emits three deprecation warnings and marks the build incompatible with Gradle 10. Only reason I touched your file.

Verified on macOS/arm64, JDK 25 as the default, full suite:

 Total: 4
Passed: 4
Failed: 0
PASS bot can interact with the server
PASS confirmation prompts tell the player how to answer (#329)
PASS open-anywhere setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#349)
PASS include-undeployed setting toggles in the admin settings GUI (#179)
BUILD SUCCESSFUL

That's the whole chain — buildChallenges → jar deploy → Paper boot → Mineflayer bots — so plugwright 2.0.2 is fine on Gradle 9, no changes needed on your side for it.

Sorry for pushing to your branch without asking first; shout if you'd rather I'd left it separate and I'll happily pull it back out.

That leaves just the two asks from my review: the scripts-only Maven wrapper, and dropping clean in favour of picking the newest jar. Do those and I'm happy to merge.

[Drownek]

Thanks @tastybento for testing this out on macOS

I've pushed a new commit addressing both points:

1. Regenerated the Maven wrapper as script-only (distributionType=only-script) and removed the binary .mvn/wrapper/maven-wrapper.jar.
2. Dropped clean from the buildChallenges Maven command and updated the task to dynamically pick the newest JAR from target/ by its modification timestamp

Should be good to merge

[tastybento]

Merged — thanks @Drownek, this is a genuinely nice quality-of-life win. ./gradlew plugwrightTest now does the whole thing from a clean checkout, which is exactly what I wanted out of it. And thanks again @mrfloris for the first pass; the exec-bit and up-to-date-checking catches were the two that mattered most.

I verified the last round on macOS/arm64 with JDK 25 as the default before merging:

Check	Result
mvnw vs upstream maven-wrapper-distribution-3.3.4-only-script	byte-identical
mvnw.cmd	identical modulo LF (matches gradlew.bat, pre-existing)
Version bump leaving both 1.8.0 and 1.9.0 jars in target/	picks 1.9.0 — confirmed via addon.yml inside the deployed jar
Dev loop, clean gone	17s cold → 6s warm
plugwrightTest, clean target/	4/4 green
mvn test, JDK 21 and 25	522/522

Nice detail worth recording: the sources jar gets an mtime identical to the second to the shaded jar, so maxByOrNull { lastModified } on its own would be a coin flip between them. The exclude("*sources*") is load-bearing, not decorative — worth not tidying away later.

I pushed one more commit (64a98f4) rather than sending you round again for small stuff:

• Bumped the distribution 3.9.6 → 3.9.12 and set distributionSha256Sum. This was the half of my wrapper comment that got missed, and it mattered more after the only-script switch than before: with the jar gone, mvnw fetches a 9 MB Maven distribution at build time, so there was no longer a committed artifact and no verification of the thing replacing it. 3.9.12 also ships newer jansi/guava, which silences the eight lines of sun.misc.Unsafe warnings 3.9.6 emits on every build under JDK 25.
• Added ../.mvn and ../mvnw as task inputs. Directly coupled to the above — without them the version bump would not have retriggered a build. Verified it does now.
• [${java.version},) in the enforcer. I nearly talked myself out of my own suggestion here: mvn help:evaluate -Dexpression=java.version returns the JVM system property (25.0.1), which would have inverted the rule. But POM plugin-configuration interpolation resolves it differently — I set <java.version> to 99 and the enforcer duly rejected JDK 25, so the pom property is what wins. Safe, and it now tracks line 42 instead of going stale.
• Dropped a stray blank line left behind by removing the Maven step from e2e.yml.

Left as follow-ups, no action needed from you: the foojay resolver and the lazy JAVA_HOME in doFirst. Both are design calls rather than fixes and I would rather make them separately.

Two things for anyone reading the red check rather than the logs:

1. The Build failure is the fork/SONAR_TOKEN limitation, not this PR. Secrets are not exposed to fork PRs, so the scanner cannot authenticate. Same on the dependabot PR, and Improve Traditional Chinese (zh-TW) translation #427/Update zh-TW.yml: complete translation coverage for v1.8.0 #429 merged through it.
2. TryToCompleteTest.testRewardChance0NoItems failed once and then passed on a rerun of the identical commit (522/522). Pre-existing intermittent flake, unrelated to build config. I had a quick look: with rewardChance 0, shouldRewardItems() is deterministically false, and every reward path is gated by it — except the level-completion rewards at TryToComplete.java:429, which call addItem ungated whenever tryCompleteLevel returns a level. So a leaked stub on that mock would produce exactly this failure. Whether level rewards should bypass the reward-chance gate is a separate question worth answering. I will raise an issue; nothing for you to do here.