fix(web): stop checkbox groups posting back options they cannot show - #465
Merged
Conversation
The enum that lets a checkbox group draw its options is also what validates the saved value. When an option goes away -- a league retires a team code, a schema drops a choice -- a config still holding the old value has no checkbox to render for it, but the value stayed in the hidden _data input anyway: that input is seeded from the stored array and only rebuilt by updateCheckboxGroupData() on change. So the stale value was posted back on every save the user did not happen to touch that widget for. The schema rejected it and the save endpoint returned 400 CONFIG_VALIDATION_FAILED, which blocks editing *any* field on that plugin until the user works out which invisible entry is at fault -- with nothing on screen naming it, because the offending value is precisely the one with no checkbox. Runtime was never affected: load_plugin() treats schema violations as warn/degrade, and a retired code already matched nothing. Only the web UI blocked. Values not in the enum are now dropped before the hidden input is seeded, and listed above the group so the selection is not lost silently. Only when the widget has options -- an empty enum means there is nothing to check against, and filtering on it would wipe the field. This is not hypothetical. ledmatrix-plugins #212 ("correct team abbreviations so config save no longer 400s") and #234 (removed the retired NHL code UTA from a picker across four plugins) are both this failure mode, fixed one league at a time. Nine shipped plugins use checkbox-group today; all of them get the fix. Tested by rendering the checkbox-group block lifted out of the shipped template, following test_enum_option_labels.py, so the tests exercise the production expression rather than a copy. Mutation-checked: removing the filter fails 2 tests, filtering unconditionally fails the empty-enum test, and dropping the notice fails the one asserting the value is named.
Contributor
|
No actionable comments were generated in the recent review. 🎉 ℹ️ Recent review info⚙️ Run configurationConfiguration used: Organization UI Review profile: CHILL Plan: Pro Plus Run ID: 📒 Files selected for processing (2)
Included review availability: Your plan provides up to 1 included review per hour; 0 remain after this review. 📝 WalkthroughWalkthroughThe checkbox-group renderer now excludes saved values that are absent from a non-empty enum and displays them in a warning. Regression tests cover stale, valid, empty-enum, all-stale, and default-value cases. ChangesCheckbox Group Stale Value Handling
Estimated code review effort: 2 (Simple) | ~10 minutes Merge Risk: ⚪ Minimal · up to This localized change filters retired checkbox values before submission while preserving empty-enum behavior and adds focused coverage; no actionable merge-blocking risk remains beyond normal checks and review. 🚥 Pre-merge checks | ✅ 4 | ❌ 1❌ Failed checks (1 warning)
✅ Passed checks (4 passed)
✨ Finishing Touches 💡 1📝 Generate docstrings 💡
🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
Up to standards ✅🟢 Issues
|
ChuckBuilds
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Sep 7, 2026
…534) * fix(core): register tom_thumb, accept frame_hold in the test double, wire api_v3's managers Three independent fixes found while validating every plugin on a 256x64 rig. FontManager never registered tom_thumb even though assets/fonts/tom-thumb.bdf ships with the core, so every plugin offering it logged "Font family 'tom_thumb' not found" (16 warnings per countdown render) and had to carry a private loader to use a bundled font. Closes #524. VisualTestDisplayManager.set_scrolling_state() lacked the frame_hold parameter that DisplayManager gained, so any plugin passing it died with TypeError at render time and failed every size. Nine plugins now make that call; ledmatrix-stocks and ledmatrix-leaderboard were failing outright and the other seven only passed because their scroll path was unreachable without data. Closes #525. api_v3 declared module-level config_manager/plugin_manager = None that nothing ever assigned -- app.py sets the blueprint attributes, which the other 150+ call sites use. Three sites read the decoys, so /health reported the config unreadable and the plugin system uninitialised (making "degraded" permanent and unreachable-by-design) and /display/current fell back to a hardcoded 128x64 on every rig. The decoys are removed rather than assigned, so a bare name is now a NameError at test time instead of a silent None. The same function's first-call uptime was computed from two separate clock reads and came out negative. Closes #529. Verified on the rig: both previously-failing plugins render, the tom_thumb warnings are gone, /health reports "healthy" with all three checks passing, and /display/current reports the real 256x64. * fix(core): unique snapshot temp name, honour on-demand requests, skip empty starlark The preview snapshot wrote through a fixed "<snapshot>.tmp". /tmp is world-writable and sticky, and the display service runs as a different user from the tooling, so a leftover temp owned by anyone else became unopenable even by root -- fs.protected_regular refuses O_CREAT on a foreign file in a sticky directory. The preview and the health check's liveness proxy then froze until someone deleted the file by hand; on the test rig that meant 23 hours of a healthy display reporting "hardware: stale". Now uses tempfile.mkstemp with cleanup on failure, matching the hardware-status write a few hundred lines above. Closes #528. _poll_on_demand_requests read its mailbox with max_age=3600, and get() defaults the in-memory TTL to max_age -- so the first request was pinned in memory for an hour and every later poll returned that stale copy. No second on-demand request was honoured until the service restarted, while the API kept returning 200. get() already documents memory_ttl=0 for exactly this cross-process case. The consumed request is also now deleted: leaving it on disk meant a restart replayed the previous request, activated it, and ignored the one the caller had just made. Closes #530. starlark-apps returned None from display() when it has no app to show, which is the state of every install without Pixlet and of a fresh one before any app is added. The controller only skips on a boolean False, so that held a black panel for the full display_duration instead of rotating on. Closes #456 (core side). Verified on the rig: two consecutive on-demand requests with no restart between them are both activated, where the second was previously dropped in silence. * perf(harness): share one cache across a plugin's renders _instantiate built a fresh MockCacheManager for every (size, mode), and that mock is a per-instance in-memory dict, so each render was a cold start. A plugin that fetches per game or per player re-fetched everything N times over -- baseball-scoreboard at one size took 840s for nine renders where the arithmetic said ~72s, and at eight sizes it exceeded a 900s timeout. The second and later renders also never exercised the cache-hit path, which is what a running rig executes almost all of the time, so a caching regression could not be caught here. The cache is now built once per render_plugin_matrix call and threaded down. The display manager stays per-render -- the bounds checking depends on that -- so only fetched data is shared. Measured on the rig, same render counts and same goldens: tide-display 2s -> 1s (32 renders) cricket-scoreboard 10s -> 3s (24 renders) No pass/fail change across tide-display, cricket-scoreboard, clock-simple, geochron, christmas-countdown, of-the-day, web-ui-info and incoming-packages. Closes #533. * fix(scripts): run standalone plugin tests instead of collecting nothing run_plugin_tests.py discovered every plugin test file and handed the lot to pytest. Most plugin tests are standalone scripts -- module-level main() plus an `if __name__ == "__main__"` guard, signalling through an exit code -- and pytest collects zero items from those. The run printed how many files it had *found*, then "no tests ran", and exited without executing any of them. On a rig with all 44 first-party plugins that is 151 of 248 files. Files are now classified and each kind runs under the right runner: pytest for real test modules, subprocess for scripts, honouring the 0 pass / 2 skip / 1 fail convention ledmatrix-plugins' own runner established (a script that wants a tty or an LED matrix is a skip, not a regression). Before: $ python3 scripts/run_plugin_tests.py -p countdown -d ~/LEDMatrix/plugin-repos Found 1 test file(s) collected 0 items no tests ran in 0.31s rc=0 After: Found 1 test file(s) -- 0 collectable, 1 standalone script(s) 1 passed, 0 skipped, 0 failed (scripts) rc=0 Verified across three shapes: countdown (1 script), jellyfin-now-playing and pomodoro-timer (pytest only, 16 and 42 tests), and ledmatrix-flights (11 files split 4 collectable / 7 scripts, all seven of which had never run). Closes #532. Running the flights scripts for the first time also surfaced four genuinely failing tests there, hidden by the mirror-image bug in the plugins repo's own runner -- filed as ChuckBuilds/ledmatrix-plugins#464 and #465. * fix(harness): give an empty-looking mode a few frames before warning about it check_plugin's "drew nothing but display() returned X" warning fired on a single frame, rendered with force_clear=True, under a frozen clock. All three defeat a scrolling plugin, whose first frame is legitimately its blank scroll-in buffer. Across 44 first-party plugins, 60 of 76 warnings were false -- the rate at which people stop reading a warning, which matters because the true positives are real: a mode that draws nothing and does not return False holds a blank panel for its whole display duration. An apparently-empty frame is now re-driven for up to 48 more frames with force_clear=False (force_clear means "reset the scroll", so repeating it would redraw frame 1 for ever) and with the clock advancing -- freezegun's factory where time is frozen, a real sleep where it is not, since scroll position is usually a function of elapsed time. The first frame that draws content replaces the result. The clock is moved back afterwards. It is shared by every render in the matrix, so time borrowed by the probe leaked into later modes and drifted their goldens -- f1_upcoming picked up 5 spurious drifts before this was restored. Measured on the rig: empty warns check before after f1-scoreboard 42 0 48 PASS / 0 FAIL, goldens intact ledmatrix-elections 16 0 16 PASS / 0 FAIL on-air 8 8 true positive, kept nfl-draft 8 8 true positive, kept clock-simple/geochron/ 0 0 unchanged christmas-countdown 58 false positives gone, both true positives kept, no golden regressions. Cost is confined to modes that really are blank: plugins that draw immediately are unchanged (clock-simple and tide-display still 2s), while on-air -- eight deliberately blank modes -- goes to 21s. Closes #527. * fix(harness): load nested schema defaults, and merge caller config at leaf level load_config_defaults read only top-level properties. An object property carries its defaults on its children, not on itself, so everything nested was dropped -- 2,386 defaults across 37 of 44 plugins, soccer-scoreboard alone losing 539 of 565. render_plugin_matrix's comment says the plugin then "behaves like a real install", which for most of the fleet it did not. _defaults_from_properties now recurses. merge_config deep-merges the caller's config onto the result so an override lands at the leaf: a shallow merge would let -c '{"nhl": {"enabled": true}}' replace the whole nhl subtree and discard every other nhl default, which is the same class of bug being fixed here. Measured before/after across all 49 installed plugins on the rig: **no render changed** -- identical PASS/FAIL counts, byte-identical output, goldens intact. Plugins already fall back to the same values internally via config.get(key, default), so supplying them explicitly agrees with what they were doing. The defaults really are arriving now: ufc-scoreboard 9 -> 87 defaults ledmatrix-flights 51 -> 95 masters-tournament 10 -> 51 cricket-scoreboard 22 -> 50 tide-display 12 -> 18 and hockey-scoreboard, which used to load nhl.enabled=None, now gets nhl.enabled=True with its full display_modes block. Caveat worth carrying: the eight plugins with the most nested config (soccer, baseball, basketball, hockey, lacrosse, football, afl, nrl -- 1,634 of the 2,386 dropped defaults, 68%) could not be measured. They import src.common.sports_shared, which the test rig's core branch predates, so they fail to load there identically before and after. Re-run this comparison against a core that has that module before trusting the "nothing changed" result for them; those are exactly the plugins whose renders should change most. Closes #531. * refactor: narrow the exception handlers this branch introduced Codacy flagged the new code; it passes on other recent PRs, so the finding is mine. Four of the five broad `except Exception` clauses I added were catching far more than they needed to, which is the same shape as several bugs this branch fixes -- hello-world's TypeError sat invisible for exactly this reason. freezer() / move_to() / tick() -> (AttributeError, TypeError, ValueError) cache_manager.delete() -> (OSError, AttributeError, KeyError) The fifth stays broad and now says why: it wraps a call into a plugin's own display(), which can raise anything, and the first frame has already rendered -- so a failure there must not turn a good result into an error. Verified against a checkout of main: f1-scoreboard 48 PASS / 0 FAIL with 0 empty warnings, on-air keeps its 8 true positives, clock-simple 8 PASS. geochron shows 7 golden drifts both before and after this branch, so it is not from these changes -- its committed goldens predate #521's 1-bit text rendering. * fix: resolve CodeRabbit review and Codacy findings on #534 CodeRabbit raised six; all six were real. The test double had drifted ahead of production. VisualTestDisplayManager accepted set_scrolling_state(frame_hold=...) while DisplayManager did not, so such a call passed every harness run and would raise TypeError on the panel -- the one failure a safety harness exists to prevent. frame_hold belongs to the change that adds it to DisplayManager (#523), so it moves there and the double matches main again. The harness swallowed exceptions from re-rendered frames. _settle_loop re-renders a mode that came back blank, to give a scroll time to draw; returning silently on a crash meant a mode that renders one good frame and then explodes was reported as passing. Recorded on result.error now, keeping the captured frame so the failure stays inspectable. starlark-apps display() returned True after _display_frame() failed, so the controller held a dead frame for the whole display_duration instead of rotating on. _display_frame now returns bool on all three paths. run_plugin_tests.py used env.setdefault for PYTHONPATH and LEDMATRIX_CORE, so an inherited value won and the subprocess imported a different core than the one under test -- ledmatrix-plugins#467 exactly. Prepends PROJECT_ROOT and sets LEDMATRIX_CORE unconditionally. The on-demand mailbox is polled after every frame, ~125x/second on a scrolling mode, and the read is deliberately uncached, so it was that many disk reads per second to find nothing. Floored at 250ms, which is imperceptible for a web-UI click. Consuming it also deleted whatever was present rather than what had just been processed, so a request posted while the previous one was in flight was thrown away and never ran; the delete is now keyed by request_id. That narrows the window rather than closing it -- a true atomic claim needs a primitive the cache layer does not offer, and the code says so rather than implying otherwise. Codacy's 2 criticals were bandit B404/B603 on the subprocess call added to run_plugin_tests.py. Fixed interpreter, argument list, no shell; annotated with the repo's existing nosec convention. Bandit is clean on the file. Adds test/test_on_demand_mailbox.py (8), test_starlark_display_contract.py (4) and two settle cases in test_harness_empty_claimed.py. 4, 4 and 2 of those fail against the pre-fix code. Full suite: 3961 passed. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014RRtqXDCnvnY6EQwhT5CV9 * chore: satisfy Codacy's subprocess checks on the new test runner Codacy runs Bandit and Opengrep (its Semgrep fork). The new subprocess.run in scripts/run_plugin_tests.py trips three patterns, on two different lines: Bandit B404 on the import, B603 on the call Opengrep dangerous-subprocess-use-audit on the run( line dangerous-subprocess-use-tainted-env-args on the argv line A nosemgrep applies only to its own line, so the call line and the argv line each need one; a single comment on the call covered neither rule fully. Suppression is the right answer here rather than a rewrite: the interpreter is sys.executable, the arguments are a list, and no shell is involved, so there is nothing to word-split or expand. Matches the pair the rest of the repo already uses for this shape -- permission_utils.py, plugin_loader.py, install_dependencies_apt.py. Codacy: 0 new issues, up to standards. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014RRtqXDCnvnY6EQwhT5CV9 * chore: leave visual_display_manager untouched so #523 can merge The only change this branch made to that file was a docstring, and it collided with #523's rewrite of the same method -- so #534 and #523 each merged cleanly against main but conflicted with each other. Reverted to main's text; #523 owns this method and adds frame_hold to it. The note the docstring carried ('frame_hold arrives in #523') would have been stale the moment #523 landed anyway. The parity test in #523 is what actually keeps the two signatures honest. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014RRtqXDCnvnY6EQwhT5CV9 * chore: add the Ruff suppression nosec/nosemgrep do not cover Ruff reports S603 on the same call Bandit and Opengrep do, and none of the three suppressions covers the others. Confirmed the precondition first: path comes from discover_plugin_tests(), which globs test files inside the repo, and the call is a fixed interpreter with a list argv and no shell. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014RRtqXDCnvnY6EQwhT5CV9 --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
The bug
The enum that lets a checkbox group draw its options is also what validates the saved value. When an option goes away — a league retires a team code, a schema drops a choice — a config still holding the old value has no checkbox to render for it, but the value stayed in the payload anyway.
The chain, in
plugin_config.html:_datainput is seeded with the stored array, unfiltered:updateCheckboxGroupData()rebuilds it from checked boxes — but onlyonchange.api_v3.pyvalidates on save and returns 400CONFIG_VALIDATION_FAILED.Net effect: a user with a retired code cannot save any change to that plugin — including edits to completely unrelated fields — and nothing on screen tells them why, because the offending value is precisely the one with no checkbox.
Runtime was never affected.
load_plugin()treats schema violations as warn/degrade ("never blocks loading"), and a retired code already matched no team. Only the web UI blocked.The fix
Drop values that aren't in the enum before seeding the hidden input, and list them above the group so the selection isn't lost silently:
Guarded on
enum_itemsdeliberately — an empty enum means there is nothing to validate against, and filtering on it would wipe the field.This is not hypothetical
Two ledmatrix-plugins PRs are this same failure mode, fixed one league at a time:
UTA, a retired NHL code, from a picker across four plugins.Real codes that trip it today:
OAK(Athletics, renamed 2025),ARI(Coyotes → Utah, 2024),SD/STL(NFL relocations), plus common non-ESPN spellings likeCWS,GSW,LAK.Nine shipped plugins use
checkbox-group— baseball, basketball, football, hockey, f1, news, odds-ticker, ledmatrix-flights, jellyfin-now-playing — and all of them get the fix.Tests
test/test_checkbox_group_stale_values.pyrenders the checkbox-group block lifted out of the shipped template, following the pattern intest_enum_option_labels.py, so it exercises the production expression rather than a copy that could drift.Mutation-checked — each fails the right test:
31 passed across
test_enum_option_labels,test_web_settings_ui,test_template_targets,test_widget_scriptsand the new file. All 20 templates still parse.🤖 Generated with Claude Code
https://claude.ai/code/session_01STMbQE4YctTacQXfbYqKuW
Summary by CodeRabbit