Skip to content

STORM-1675 - Allow submitting multiple jars from the client - #1296

Closed
abhishekagarwal87 wants to merge 1 commit into
apache:masterfrom
abhishekagarwal87:multi-jar
Closed

STORM-1675 - Allow submitting multiple jars from the client#1296
abhishekagarwal87 wants to merge 1 commit into
apache:masterfrom
abhishekagarwal87:multi-jar

Conversation

@abhishekagarwal87

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

The PR is not complete yet and needs some refinements. I wanted to get some feedback first. I tried out multiple approaches -

  1. Submitting individual jar one by one - Right now the stormjar has a hardcoded key so that both supervisor and nimbus can download/upload the jar. This becomes complicated if there is more than one jar. The keys for all the jars have to be passed from nimbus to supervisor. Then these keys have to be updated, removed, waited--upon-for-code-replication etc.
  2. Build an app-assembly jar programmatically - It is not desired as it changes the internal structure of jar. which can result in unknown issues e.g. manifests have to be handled correctly.
  3. Packing jars into a zip, upload it and unzip it and supervisor - This is the current approach. It seemed to me the cleanest approach.

I tested out word-count-topology with two jars and they were added to classpath correctly -
/usr/local/storm/apache-storm-2.0.0-SNAPSHOT/bin/storm jar /usr/local/storm/apache-storm-2.0.0-SNAPSHOT/lib/kryo-3.0.3.jar:../../examples/storm-starter/target/storm-starter-2.0.0-SNAPSHOT.jar:../../examples/storm-starter/multilang/resources:../../storm-multilang/python/src/main/resources/resources org.apache.storm.starter.WordCountTopology remote

I can also add an option to turn zip/unzip off for single jar topologies.

@abhishekagarwal87

Copy link
Copy Markdown
ContributorAuthor

Any comments/suggestions?

@HeartSaVioR

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

I think STORM-2016 covers this, so we can close this.
@abhishekagarwal87 What do you think?

d2r pushed a commit to d2r/storm that referenced this pull request Oct 16, 2018
We are closing stale Pull Requests to make the list more manageable.
Please re-open any Pull Request that has been closed in error.
Closesapache#608Closesapache#639Closesapache#640Closesapache#648Closesapache#662Closesapache#668Closesapache#692Closesapache#705Closesapache#724Closesapache#728Closesapache#730Closesapache#753Closesapache#803Closesapache#854Closesapache#922Closesapache#986Closesapache#992Closesapache#1019Closesapache#1040Closesapache#1041Closesapache#1043Closesapache#1046Closesapache#1051Closesapache#1078Closesapache#1146Closesapache#1164Closesapache#1165Closesapache#1178Closesapache#1213Closesapache#1225Closesapache#1258Closesapache#1259Closesapache#1268Closesapache#1272Closesapache#1277Closesapache#1278Closesapache#1288Closesapache#1296Closesapache#1328Closesapache#1342Closesapache#1353Closesapache#1370Closesapache#1376Closesapache#1391Closesapache#1395Closesapache#1399Closesapache#1406Closesapache#1410Closesapache#1422Closesapache#1427Closesapache#1443Closesapache#1462Closesapache#1468Closesapache#1483Closesapache#1506Closesapache#1509Closesapache#1515Closesapache#1520Closesapache#1521Closesapache#1525Closesapache#1527Closesapache#1544Closesapache#1550Closesapache#1566Closesapache#1569Closesapache#1570Closesapache#1575Closesapache#1580Closesapache#1584Closesapache#1591Closesapache#1600Closesapache#1611Closesapache#1613Closesapache#1639Closesapache#1703Closesapache#1711Closesapache#1719Closesapache#1737Closesapache#1760Closesapache#1767Closesapache#1768Closesapache#1785Closesapache#1799Closesapache#1822Closesapache#1824Closesapache#1844Closesapache#1874Closesapache#1918Closesapache#1928Closesapache#1937Closesapache#1942Closesapache#1951Closesapache#1957Closesapache#1963Closesapache#1964Closesapache#1965Closesapache#1967Closesapache#1968Closesapache#1971Closesapache#1985Closesapache#1986Closesapache#1998Closesapache#2031Closesapache#2032Closesapache#2071Closesapache#2076Closesapache#2108Closesapache#2119Closesapache#2128Closesapache#2142Closesapache#2174Closesapache#2206Closesapache#2297Closesapache#2322Closesapache#2332Closesapache#2341Closesapache#2377Closesapache#2414Closesapache#2469
d2r pushed a commit to d2r/storm that referenced this pull request Oct 16, 2018
We are closing stale Pull Requests to make the list more manageable.
Please re-open any Pull Request that has been closed in error.
Closesapache#608Closesapache#639Closesapache#640Closesapache#648Closesapache#662Closesapache#668Closesapache#692Closesapache#705Closesapache#724Closesapache#728Closesapache#730Closesapache#753Closesapache#803Closesapache#854Closesapache#922Closesapache#986Closesapache#992Closesapache#1019Closesapache#1040Closesapache#1041Closesapache#1043Closesapache#1046Closesapache#1051Closesapache#1078Closesapache#1146Closesapache#1164Closesapache#1165Closesapache#1178Closesapache#1213Closesapache#1225Closesapache#1258Closesapache#1259Closesapache#1268Closesapache#1272Closesapache#1277Closesapache#1278Closesapache#1288Closesapache#1296Closesapache#1328Closesapache#1342Closesapache#1353Closesapache#1370Closesapache#1376Closesapache#1391Closesapache#1395Closesapache#1399Closesapache#1406Closesapache#1410Closesapache#1422Closesapache#1427Closesapache#1443Closesapache#1462Closesapache#1468Closesapache#1483Closesapache#1506Closesapache#1509Closesapache#1515Closesapache#1520Closesapache#1521Closesapache#1525Closesapache#1527Closesapache#1544Closesapache#1550Closesapache#1566Closesapache#1569Closesapache#1570Closesapache#1575Closesapache#1580Closesapache#1584Closesapache#1591Closesapache#1600Closesapache#1611Closesapache#1613Closesapache#1639Closesapache#1703Closesapache#1711Closesapache#1719Closesapache#1737Closesapache#1760Closesapache#1767Closesapache#1768Closesapache#1785Closesapache#1799Closesapache#1822Closesapache#1824Closesapache#1844Closesapache#1874Closesapache#1918Closesapache#1928Closesapache#1937Closesapache#1942Closesapache#1951Closesapache#1957Closesapache#1963Closesapache#1964Closesapache#1965Closesapache#1967Closesapache#1968Closesapache#1971Closesapache#1985Closesapache#1986Closesapache#1998Closesapache#2031Closesapache#2032Closesapache#2071Closesapache#2076Closesapache#2108Closesapache#2119Closesapache#2128Closesapache#2142Closesapache#2174Closesapache#2206Closesapache#2297Closesapache#2322Closesapache#2332Closesapache#2341Closesapache#2377Closesapache#2414Closesapache#2469
Sign up for freeto join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants

@abhishekagarwal87@HeartSaVioR