skills(data): optimization flight — hooks consolidated, generic patterns cut, sharingModel/Field.* /storage.notNull taught (net −9,044 tokens)

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1

[os-litant]

Part of #14297

Optimization flight for skills/objectstack-data, the largest package in the published
catalog. Implements the card's IMPLEMENT scope from the 43-row audit record (posted
verbatim as a comment on the card). Governed surface (skills/** markdown) ⇒ this PR
stays draft; needs:contract-review is on both carriers because INC-01 corrects a
contract-semantics claim.

Net: 45,780 → 36,736 hand-authored tokens (−9,044, −19.8%). One published file
deleted, none added, no ceiling raised, every ratcheted file byte-neutral-or-shrinking.

Per-file token delta

File	before	after	Δ	ceiling	headroom
SKILL.md	13,892	12,553	−1,339	13,892	1,339
references/data-hooks.md	12,584	9,703	−2,881	12,611	2,908
rules/hooks.md	2,195	deleted	−2,195	row dropped	—
rules/indexing.md	3,240	2,166	−1,074	3,241	1,075
rules/validation.md	3,109	2,362	−747	3,109	747
rules/naming.md	773	248	−525	773	525
rules/relationships.md	3,773	3,490	−283	3,778	288
rules/field-types.md	3,578	3,578	0	3,584	6
rules/lifecycle.md	1,590	1,590	0	1,590	0
rules/datasources.md	903	903	0	911	8
evals/README.md	143	143	0	143	0
package	45,780	36,736	−9,044

references/_index.md (generated, 1,483) untouched.

Two rows differ from the card's projection and are called out rather than forced:

• rules/field-types.md nets 0, not −50. DATA-D-14 paid −200; the DATA-E-03
  Field.* preamble is what it bought. Cross-file payment is not available (the ratchet
  is per file), so the addition was trimmed twice until it fit inside D-14's payment. The
  file does not grow.
• evals/README.md unchanged. DATA-H-01 raises a ceiling and is on the card's DEFER
  list.

落点 | before | after

finding	落点	before	after
DATA-B-01 / I-03	rules/hooks.md (whole file)	2,195 tok calling itself "a reference pointer", then restating 5 sections of the canonical file	deleted; references/data-hooks.md is the single hooks file and the catalog's hooks anchor. Ceiling row dropped
DATA-B-02	data-hooks.md:1-26	two H1s, two intros saying the same thing, a "When to Use This Skill" inside a reference	one H1, one intro
DATA-B-03	8-event table ∥ in both files	stated in full twice (466 + 525 tok)	one copy (the canonical file's), via the file deletion
DATA-B-04	data-hooks.md:1050-1133	three registration methods in 566 tok	compact, 4 load-bearing facts kept: AppPlugin auto-binds, the functions map, packageId, and that programmatic binding gets no declarative condition/retry/timeout/onError/async semantics
DATA-B-05	data-hooks.md:1136-1160	10+10 generic DO/DON'T	the compact 5+5 rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-B-07	7 sites	"no unique validation type" stated seven times	restatements in validation.md + relationships.md dropped; SKILL.md + the indexing.md scope table keep it
DATA-C-01	SKILL.md:162-189	two verbatim CLI/HTTP error transcripts (the 400 text word-for-word in objectstack-query)	3 lines naming both refusals; the modelling half (mirror field + two-hook maintenance table) stays — this package is its anchor
DATA-C-02	validation.md:26-36, 313-331	CEL-vs-SQL prose + a ❌/✅ pair	pointer to objectstack-formula (the anchor); the inversion rule stays, it lives nowhere else
DATA-C-03	data-hooks.md:1209-1275	vitest + LiteKernel harnesses importing 4 unresolvable packages	one-line pointer to objectstack-platform, whose frontmatter claims that surface
DATA-C-04	5 tombstone sites	standalone narration of removed keys (rls, encryptionConfig, tenancy.strategy, softDelete/versioning, type/partial)	deleted; each key is refused by a parse error carrying its own prescription, and objectstack-upgrade owns in-place upgrades. In-line ❌ markers kept where a wrong key sits beside the right one
DATA-C-05	SKILL.md:858-971	987 tok: 3 near-identical examples for a 4-value enum + Studio-banner narration + 5-bullet guidance	schema block + 4-row lock table + ONE example + 4 lines of enforcement
DATA-D-01/02/03	data-hooks.md:1279-1444	invented benchmark table (0 hooks ~1ms…), plain-JS "Advanced Topics", generic Troubleshooting, a Summary repeating the DO list verbatim	deleted; the References block survives and absorbs the two cross-package pointers rules/hooks.md carried
DATA-D-04	data-hooks.md:765-1046	10 patterns, 6 of them plain JavaScript	patterns 1,2,4,5,7,9 deleted; 3,6,8,10 kept and renumbered
DATA-D-05/06/07	rules/indexing.md	RDBMS 101, one textbook fact taught seven ways, unsourced Table Size → Max Indexes, pg_stat_user_indexes SQL, 10 best practices	one paragraph on composite order; naming block kept (name is a declared key)
DATA-D-08	relationships.md:398-413	7 + 4 items restating the file's own tables	deleted
DATA-D-09/D-10	validation.md:355-438	5 patterns restating 4 examples on the same page; 10 best practices + 4 unsourced perf claims	deleted
DATA-D-11	naming.md:15-107	6 ❌/✅ pairs + restatements + rationale for a rule the regex already states	table + Critical Rules (773 → 248)
DATA-D-12	SKILL.md:540-555	"CRM Schema Blueprint" pointing at 6 things covered above it	deleted
DATA-D-13	SKILL.md:974-987	"Advanced Features Checklist" + tombstone footnote	deleted
DATA-D-14	field-types.md:360-411	3 ❌/✅ pairs duplicating naming.md, the type table, and a lint rule	deleted (autonumber pair survives) — funds DATA-E-03
DATA-D-15	SKILL.md:1178-1181	the live model-benchmarking door	deleted (platform benchmarking, not app authoring)
DATA-E-01/E-02	2 blocks	self-contained blocks opening { / validations: [ at statement position (TS parses that as a labelled-statement block)	real declarations; os:check markers added to the two SKILL.md blocks that compile
DATA-E-03 / G-02	rules/field-types.md	zero Field.* in the file whose job is field authoring; corpus is ~92% factory	Field.* preamble with the literal ↔ factory mapping
DATA-E-04	data-hooks.md patterns	file prescribed body, demonstrated deprecated handler 10 times	2 surviving patterns converted to sandboxed body with declared capabilities
DATA-E-05	SKILL.md:325-379	the one copy-pasteable object diverged from all 31 real ones	pluralLabel/description/icon/highlightFields added, indexes dropped (1 of 26 corpus files)
DATA-F-01	SKILL.md:64-84	sharingModel on 31/31 real objects, absent from both property tables	required-table row + 4-row value table
DATA-F-02	SKILL.md:383-403	storage.notNull never mentioned in the package	required = write contract, storage.notNull = the DDL
DATA-F-03	SKILL.md:71-84	icon/pluralLabel/highlightFields undocumented	three rows
DATA-F-04	SKILL.md:1142-1152	9 data-model lint rules, 0 security rules	4 security rows, 3 of them publish-blocking
DATA-F-05	SKILL.md	defineObjectExtension, readScope/writeScope — zero corpus usage	shrunk to one schema-pointing row each, not deleted (retirement deferred pending #14296; zero usage in examples is evidence, not proof)
DATA-F-06	SKILL.md:1129 + frontmatter	prescribed {object}.seed.ts; find . -name '*.seed.ts' returns 0 repo-wide	row deleted, trigger aligned to src/data/*.ts
DATA-G-01	6 sites	objectstack lint and os lint in one file, 60 lines apart	normalised to os
INC-01	SKILL.md:393	required: true → false "dev auto-heals (autoMigrate:'safe')"	corrected — see below
INC-02	SKILL.md:398-401	stale NOT NULL produces a clean 400	corrected — raw driver error

Contract-semantics corrections (why needs:contract-review)

INC-01. The schema-evolution table named the wrong dial and claimed auto-healing. Both
halves are false against the implementation:

• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/schema-drift.ts:795-798 — const expectNullable = field.storage?.notNull !== true; under a comment reading "compared against
  storage.notNull, the explicit physical constraint — NOT against required, which is
  the write-time contract and implies nothing about the column".
• The emitted drift is severity: 'warning', category: 'needs_confirm',
  op: { type: 'relax_not_null' } (schema-drift.ts:815-826), above a comment saying
  "never auto-applied".
• packages/drivers/driver-sql/src/sql-driver.ts:10746 — const safe = drift.filter((d) => d.category === 'safe');. autoMigrate: 'safe' applies only category safe, so
  it never touches this op.

INC-02.schema-drift.ts:800-802 says that exact configuration means "an omitting
write reaches the DB and dies as a raw driver error instead of a clean validation 400" —
the opposite symptom to the one the tell-tale promised.

INC-03 (new, found while rewriting DATA-D-04 pattern 8). The file asserted "There is
NO updateMany" a few hundred lines below a capability table listing updateMany as
"also installed". Both are true of different surfaces and neither said which:
ObjectRepository — what a handler's ctx.api.object() returns
(packages/objectql/src/engine.ts:13563-13600) — has no updateMany; the sandbox repo
does (packages/runtime/src/sandbox/quickjs-runner.ts:544-545). The comment now names its
surface. This is why patterns 3 and 6 were converted to body and pattern 8 was left as a
handler.

premise_false

None. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data was EMPTY at my base
909a4417, so all 43 spans resolved byte-identically and no finding had to be skipped.

One card-level detail did not hold, and needed no action: the card's ANCHOR RULINGS says
the inbound link at rules/hooks.md:202 points at objectstack-platform
rules/plugin-hooks-events.md and must be re-pointed. At base it already pointed at
objectstack-platform/references/plugin-hooks.md. The file is deleted here anyway, and
that pointer is preserved in the surviving References block.

PM mechanical assumptions — measured

1. Spans byte-identical at a59f78d. TRUE. git diff --stat a59f78d HEAD -- skills/objectstack-data empty; git diff --stat d63c8a25 HEAD -- skills/ empty;
   the ratchet script unchanged since the pin.
2. Does check:skill-docs demand regenerating skills/README.md?YES, and it runs
   in CI (.github/workflows/lint.yml:3986). The frontmatter description changed, the
   gate failed, and pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec gen:skill-docs regenerated
   skills/README.mdandcontent/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — the second file was
   not in the assumption. Both diffs are one data-row each. check:skill-refs is green
   and references/_index.md is untouched.
3. Deleting rules/hooks.md reds the ratchet unless its ceiling row goes. TRUE, and
   verified in both directions from a committed state with a restore trap: with the row
   re-injected the gate prints ✗ check-skills-token-ratchet: cannot read skills/objectstack-data/rules/hooks.md — red, not a skip (#4690) and exits 1; restored
   (blob hash equal to HEAD, git diff HEAD empty) it exits 0.
4. The os:check rule is in the header of check-skill-examples.ts. TRUE (lines
   17-23): a marker is os:check in an HTML comment on the line directly above the fence.
   The seven would-fail blocks were handled as the audit proposed — 2 repaired, 2 deleted
   with DATA-C-03, 3 left unmarked (they import unresolvable paths). Markers were added
   only after the gate proved they pass: 261 marked blocks type-check.
5. A finding whose premise is false is skipped. None were.

Follow-ups by package

• objectstack-platform — references/plugin-hooks.md:77 routes readers to the
  objectstack-data skill "(rules/hooks.md, …)", the file this PR deletes. It is another
  package, so it is untouched here; the platform flight (Skills optimization flight — skills/objectstack-platform: RESTRUCTURE (≈ −5,970 tok, −25%) — an orphan rules file with zero inbound links, the canonical hooks reference two hops from the entry file, "When to Use" printed twice, and requires: / engines.protocol / onEnable (every real config) taught nowhere #14299) should re-point it to
  references/data-hooks.md. No gate reads it (check:published-readme-links is scoped to
  package READMEs, not skills/**), so nothing is red today.
• objectstack-platform — DATA-C-03 removed the LiteKernel/vitest hook harnesses from
  this package and left a pointer. Platform's frontmatter already claims "test harnesses
  via LiteKernel"; it does not yet carry a hook-testing example for the pointer to land on.
• maintainer decision (DATA-F-07, deferred by the card) — defineHook() is prescribed
  twice, but grep -rln defineHook --include='*.ts' outside packages/spec and
  packages/cli returns 0 files, and both real hook modules use the bare : Hook literal
  (examples/app-crm/src/hooks/opportunity.hook.ts:10,
  examples/app-todo/src/objects/task.hook.ts:51). Either the examples move to
  defineHook() or the prescription softens; it is not a doc edit.
• deferred with the card — DATA-I-04 (a new rules/security.md; would add a file),
  DATA-H-01 (would raise the evals/README.md ceiling), DATA-B-06 (moving the routing
  table up: a MOVE-TO, which is not among the card's three IMPLEMENT verbs, and its only
  named MOVE-TO sibling is deferred). DATA-D-11 is MED confidence with the audit noting a
  maintainer may want one ❌/✅ pair kept — restoring one is a cheap review edit.

Edits outside the declared file surface

The card scoped this to skills/objectstack-data/** plus the one ratchet ceiling row.
Three further files are in the diff. Each is fallout of the mandated deletion, each was
prescribed by the failing gate itself, and each shrinks:

1. scripts/check-skill-identifier-liveness.mjs — the hook-lifecycle-events-rule ledger
   row binds the heading ### 8 Lifecycle Eventsinside the deleted file, so the gate
   went red. Its message prescribes "Re-point heading, or delete the row". Re-pointing
   would duplicate hook-lifecycle-events-reference, which already binds the same symbol
   (HookEvent) to the surviving canonical file, so the row is dropped. Separately, the
   DATA-F-05 shrink had incidentally renamed another ledger-bound heading
   (### Access depth (scope-depth) …); there the ledger is right and the rename was
   reverted in SKILL.md.
2. scripts/role-word-baseline.json — the deletions removed two role-word occurrences from
   SKILL.md, so check:role-word failed as a ratchet-DOWN: "count improved 4 → 2 —
   run node scripts/check-role-word.mjs --update and commit the baseline". That direction
   is the author's own remedy (expansion is the maintainer-only one). One line, shrinking.
3. skills/README.md + content/docs/ai/skills-reference.mdx — generated, regenerated by
   the sanctioned generator, as assumption 2 above records.

Gates — head 061e5f4c

Run with exit codes captured before any pipe. Heavy builds went through
scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh.

The four gates named on the card:

gate	verdict line
node scripts/check-skills-token-ratchet.mjs	✓ 37 authored bundle file(s) within their ceilings (was 38; one file deleted)
pnpm --filter @objectstack/spec check:skill-examples	✅ 261 prose examples type-check across 3 surface(s)
pnpm check:skill-compatibility	✓ 11 SKILL.md file(s) reconciled against 78 workspace packages
pnpm check:skill-identifier-liveness	OK — Leg 1: 492 citation(s) over 47 published file(s); Leg 2: 8 registered exhaustive section(s), 0 ledgered gap(s)

Plus the full family node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack
derives for the real 13-path change set — 55 gates, re-derived and re-run on this head:
53 exit 0. The two non-zero are exit 3 = NOT MEASURED by the gates' own definition, not
reds:

• node scripts/check-test-completeness.mjs — "There is no local log to hand it, so the
  local reading for this gate is NOT MEASURED. ⛔ It is not a red." It wants a saved
  turbo run test log.
• node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs — needs the GitHub API, which is 403 from this
  container.

Ratchet self-test green (64 cases pass). check:skill-docs, check:skill-refs,
check:role-word, check:doc-authoring, check:corpus-claim-drift,
check:pm-governed-merges, check:ratchet-remedy-authority all green on this head.

skip-changeset applies: docs-only, publishing nothing from any package.

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01LraLgQVGq8egUwfYZpbYt1