Skip to content

chore: remove closed bootstrap markers from Workflows - #3309

Merged
stranske merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
codex/issue-3306-remove-bootstrap-markers
Sep 2, 2026
Merged

stranske merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
codex/issue-3306-remove-bootstrap-markers

Conversation

@stranske

@stranske stranske commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

Implements the Workflows slice of #3306: removes 135 closed/merged-item bootstrap-path files while retaining agents/codex-output.md and agents/codex-prompt.md.

The issue intentionally spans four repositories. This PR is the single Workflows commit/PR; its remaining repo-local slices are not included here.

Live lineage revalidation

Before deletion, every listed Workflows item was re-resolved through GraphQL: 135/135 CLOSED or MERGED; 0 OPEN or missing.

Path live item state
agents/auto-pilot-755.md issue #755 CLOSED
agents/auto-pilot-763.md issue #763 CLOSED
agents/auto-pilot-768.md issue #768 CLOSED
agents/auto-pilot-771.md issue #771 CLOSED
agents/auto-pilot-785.md issue #785 CLOSED
agents/auto-pilot-821.md issue #821 CLOSED
agents/codex-2.md issue #2 CLOSED
agents/codex-4.md issue #4 CLOSED
agents/codex-8.md issue #8 CLOSED
agents/codex-9.md issue #9 CLOSED
agents/codex-10.md issue #10 CLOSED
agents/codex-11.md issue #11 CLOSED
agents/codex-12.md issue #12 CLOSED
agents/codex-13.md issue #13 CLOSED
agents/codex-14.md issue #14 CLOSED
agents/codex-15.md issue #15 CLOSED
agents/codex-16.md issue #16 CLOSED
agents/codex-17.md issue #17 CLOSED
agents/codex-23.md issue #23 CLOSED
agents/codex-73.md issue #73 CLOSED
agents/codex-74.md issue #74 CLOSED
agents/codex-75.md issue #75 CLOSED
agents/codex-76.md issue #76 CLOSED
agents/codex-77.md issue #77 CLOSED
agents/codex-78.md issue #78 CLOSED
agents/codex-79.md issue #79 CLOSED
agents/codex-92.md issue #92 CLOSED
agents/codex-93.md issue #93 CLOSED
agents/codex-101.md issue #101 CLOSED
agents/codex-123.md issue #123 CLOSED
agents/codex-144.md issue #144 CLOSED
agents/codex-153.md issue #153 CLOSED
agents/codex-157.md issue #157 CLOSED
agents/codex-160.md issue #160 CLOSED
agents/codex-164.md issue #164 CLOSED
agents/codex-167.md issue #167 CLOSED
agents/codex-170.md issue #170 CLOSED
agents/codex-213.md issue #213 CLOSED
agents/codex-271.md issue #271 CLOSED
agents/codex-287.md issue #287 CLOSED
agents/codex-288.md issue #288 CLOSED
agents/codex-297.md issue #297 CLOSED
agents/codex-299.md issue #299 CLOSED
agents/codex-302.md issue #302 CLOSED
agents/codex-356.md issue #356 CLOSED
agents/codex-359.md issue #359 CLOSED
agents/codex-362.md issue #362 CLOSED
agents/codex-365.md issue #365 CLOSED
agents/codex-368.md issue #368 CLOSED
agents/codex-371.md issue #371 CLOSED
agents/codex-377.md issue #377 CLOSED
agents/codex-380.md issue #380 CLOSED
agents/codex-387.md issue #387 CLOSED
agents/codex-392.md issue #392 CLOSED
agents/codex-397.md issue #397 CLOSED
agents/codex-399.md issue #399 CLOSED
agents/codex-405.md issue #405 CLOSED
agents/codex-439.md issue #439 CLOSED
agents/codex-453.md issue #453 CLOSED
agents/codex-454.md issue #454 CLOSED
agents/codex-455.md issue #455 CLOSED
agents/codex-456.md issue #456 CLOSED
agents/codex-457.md issue #457 CLOSED
agents/codex-477.md issue #477 CLOSED
agents/codex-478.md issue #478 CLOSED
agents/codex-480.md issue #480 CLOSED
agents/codex-481.md issue #481 CLOSED
agents/codex-482.md issue #482 CLOSED
agents/codex-483.md issue #483 CLOSED
agents/codex-518.md issue #518 CLOSED
agents/codex-540.md issue #540 CLOSED
agents/codex-545.md issue #545 CLOSED
agents/codex-567.md issue #567 CLOSED
agents/codex-581.md issue #581 CLOSED
agents/codex-582.md issue #582 CLOSED
agents/codex-690.md issue #690 CLOSED
agents/codex-692.md issue #692 CLOSED
agents/codex-693.md issue #693 CLOSED
agents/codex-719.md issue #719 CLOSED
agents/codex-723.md issue #723 CLOSED
agents/codex-725.md issue #725 CLOSED
agents/codex-729.md issue #729 CLOSED
agents/codex-875.md issue #875 CLOSED
agents/codex-893.md issue #893 CLOSED
agents/codex-895.md issue #895 CLOSED
agents/codex-922.md issue #922 CLOSED
agents/codex-935.md issue #935 CLOSED
agents/codex-936.md issue #936 CLOSED
agents/codex-942.md issue #942 CLOSED
agents/codex-970.md issue #970 CLOSED
agents/codex-982.md issue #982 CLOSED
agents/codex-983.md issue #983 CLOSED
agents/codex-988.md issue #988 CLOSED
agents/codex-989.md issue #989 CLOSED
agents/codex-992.md issue #992 CLOSED
agents/codex-994.md issue #994 CLOSED
agents/codex-1001.md issue #1001 CLOSED
agents/codex-1003.md issue #1003 CLOSED
agents/codex-1005.md issue #1005 CLOSED
agents/codex-1006.md issue #1006 CLOSED
agents/codex-1011.md issue #1011 CLOSED
agents/codex-1015.md issue #1015 CLOSED
agents/codex-1021.md issue #1021 CLOSED
agents/codex-1025.md issue #1025 CLOSED
agents/codex-1026.md issue #1026 CLOSED
agents/codex-1038.md issue #1038 CLOSED
agents/codex-1039.md issue #1039 CLOSED
agents/codex-1063.md issue #1063 CLOSED
agents/codex-1267.md issue #1267 CLOSED
agents/codex-1279.md PR #1279 MERGED
agents/codex-1296.md issue #1296 CLOSED
agents/codex-1322.md issue #1322 CLOSED
agents/codex-1331.md issue #1331 CLOSED
agents/codex-1334.md PR #1334 MERGED
agents/codex-1342.md issue #1342 CLOSED
agents/codex-1353.md issue #1353 CLOSED
agents/codex-1355.md issue #1355 CLOSED
agents/codex-1365.md issue #1365 CLOSED
agents/codex-1366.md issue #1366 CLOSED
agents/codex-1371.md issue #1371 CLOSED
agents/codex-1385.md issue #1385 CLOSED
agents/codex-1387.md PR #1387 MERGED
agents/codex-1395.md issue #1395 CLOSED
agents/codex-1404.md issue #1404 CLOSED
agents/codex-1406.md issue #1406 CLOSED
agents/codex-1407.md issue #1407 CLOSED
agents/codex-1416.md issue #1416 CLOSED
agents/codex-1417.md PR #1417 MERGED
agents/codex-1419.md PR #1419 MERGED
agents/codex-1425.md issue #1425 CLOSED
agents/codex-1447.md PR #1447 MERGED
agents/codex-1467.md PR #1467 MERGED
agents/codex-1502.md PR #1502 MERGED
agents/codex-1638.md PR #1638 MERGED
agents/format-580.md issue #580 CLOSED

Validation

  • pytest tests/workflows/test_issue_bridge_seed.py — 4 passed
  • Local implementation of the issue's named path-shape check — PASS Workflows (0 bootstrap-path files)
  • git diff --cached --check — passed

The remote REF=codex/issue-3306-remove-bootstrap-markers acceptance check and deliberate-break/revert are recorded in the follow-up PR comment after the branch is available.

Verifier context (post-merge metadata repair)

The original PR body recorded the live lineage table and validation, but omitted the structured headings consumed by the post-merge verifier. These checked items restate that existing evidence so the already-applied verify:compare route can produce a durable report.

Tasks

  • Remove the 135 Workflows bootstrap-path files whose linked issue or PR was re-resolved as CLOSED or MERGED.
  • Preserve agents/codex-output.md and agents/codex-prompt.md.
  • Run the issue-bridge seed test and the Workflows path-shape acceptance check.

Acceptance Criteria

  • The Workflows default branch has zero agents/<agent>-<number>.md bootstrap-path files.
  • pytest tests/workflows/test_issue_bridge_seed.py passed (4 tests).
  • Every deleted path is represented in the PR body lineage table with CLOSED or MERGED state, with no OPEN item removed.
  • The two live status files remain present.

Copilot AI lite review requested due to automatic review settings September 2, 2026 04:06
@stranske stranske added agent:codex Agent-created issues from Codex agents:keepalive Use to initiate keepalive functionality with agents autofix Opt-in automated formatting & lint remediation labels Sep 2, 2026
@chatgpt-codex-connector

chatgpt-codex-connector Bot commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Codex Review Summary

This comment shows the latest Codex review activity on this pull request.

Review Status Commit Review trigger
📝 Code Review Completed 2026-09-02T04:08:39.051947Z 873726d PR opened
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review" or "@codex security review".

Codex reacts with 👀 while any review is running, comments if it has suggestions, and reacts with 👍 once all reviews finish with no findings.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Warning

Review limit reached

Next included review available in 23 minutes.

Check out review usage here.

View limit details

Limit details: You’ve used all 2 included reviews currently available. Your 57 included PR review attempts over the past 7 days set your current allowance at 2 reviews per hour.

Your organization has reached its usage spending cap. Adjust your spending cap in the billing tab.

Learn how review limits work.

Review configuration:

⚙️ Run configuration

Configuration used: Path: .coderabbit.yaml

Review profile: ASSERTIVE

Plan: Essentials

Run ID: d9b93ded-0a6a-459a-b11a-32f2b8daba23

📥 Commits

Reviewing files that changed from the base of the PR and between 28b0f20 and 769402d.

📒 Files selected for processing (136)
  • agents/auto-pilot-755.md
  • agents/auto-pilot-763.md
  • agents/auto-pilot-768.md
  • agents/auto-pilot-771.md
  • agents/auto-pilot-785.md
  • agents/auto-pilot-821.md
  • agents/codex-10.md
  • agents/codex-1001.md
  • agents/codex-1003.md
  • agents/codex-1005.md
  • agents/codex-1006.md
  • agents/codex-101.md
  • agents/codex-1011.md
  • agents/codex-1015.md
  • agents/codex-1021.md
  • agents/codex-1025.md
  • agents/codex-1026.md
  • agents/codex-1038.md
  • agents/codex-1039.md
  • agents/codex-1063.md
  • agents/codex-11.md
  • agents/codex-12.md
  • agents/codex-123.md
  • agents/codex-1267.md
  • agents/codex-1279.md
  • agents/codex-1296.md
  • agents/codex-13.md
  • agents/codex-1322.md
  • agents/codex-1331.md
  • agents/codex-1334.md
  • agents/codex-1342.md
  • agents/codex-1353.md
  • agents/codex-1355.md
  • agents/codex-1365.md
  • agents/codex-1366.md
  • agents/codex-1371.md
  • agents/codex-1385.md
  • agents/codex-1387.md
  • agents/codex-1395.md
  • agents/codex-14.md
  • agents/codex-1404.md
  • agents/codex-1406.md
  • agents/codex-1407.md
  • agents/codex-1416.md
  • agents/codex-1417.md
  • agents/codex-1419.md
  • agents/codex-1425.md
  • agents/codex-144.md
  • agents/codex-1467.md
  • agents/codex-15.md
  • agents/codex-1502.md
  • agents/codex-153.md
  • agents/codex-157.md
  • agents/codex-16.md
  • agents/codex-160.md
  • agents/codex-1638.md
  • agents/codex-164.md
  • agents/codex-167.md
  • agents/codex-17.md
  • agents/codex-170.md
  • agents/codex-2.md
  • agents/codex-213.md
  • agents/codex-23.md
  • agents/codex-271.md
  • agents/codex-287.md
  • agents/codex-288.md
  • agents/codex-297.md
  • agents/codex-299.md
  • agents/codex-302.md
  • agents/codex-356.md
  • agents/codex-359.md
  • agents/codex-362.md
  • agents/codex-365.md
  • agents/codex-368.md
  • agents/codex-371.md
  • agents/codex-377.md
  • agents/codex-380.md
  • agents/codex-387.md
  • agents/codex-392.md
  • agents/codex-397.md
  • agents/codex-399.md
  • agents/codex-4.md
  • agents/codex-405.md
  • agents/codex-439.md
  • agents/codex-453.md
  • agents/codex-454.md
  • agents/codex-455.md
  • agents/codex-456.md
  • agents/codex-457.md
  • agents/codex-477.md
  • agents/codex-478.md
  • agents/codex-480.md
  • agents/codex-481.md
  • agents/codex-482.md
  • agents/codex-483.md
  • agents/codex-518.md
  • agents/codex-540.md
  • agents/codex-545.md
  • agents/codex-567.md
  • agents/codex-581.md
  • agents/codex-582.md
  • agents/codex-690.md
  • agents/codex-692.md
  • agents/codex-693.md
  • agents/codex-719.md
  • agents/codex-723.md
  • agents/codex-725.md
  • agents/codex-729.md
  • agents/codex-73.md
  • agents/codex-74.md
  • agents/codex-75.md
  • agents/codex-76.md
  • agents/codex-77.md
  • agents/codex-78.md
  • agents/codex-79.md
  • agents/codex-8.md
  • agents/codex-875.md
  • agents/codex-893.md
  • agents/codex-895.md
  • agents/codex-9.md
  • agents/codex-92.md
  • agents/codex-922.md
  • agents/codex-93.md
  • agents/codex-935.md
  • agents/codex-936.md
  • agents/codex-942.md
  • agents/codex-970.md
  • agents/codex-982.md
  • agents/codex-983.md
  • agents/codex-988.md
  • agents/codex-989.md
  • agents/codex-992.md
  • agents/codex-994.md
  • agents/format-580.md
  • tests/workflows/fixtures/needs_human_comment.md
  • tests/workflows/test_workflow_llm_installs.py

Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.

@stranske-keepalive

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Workflow source needed

PR #3309 needs either a linked GitHub issue or one valid non-issue Workflow Source before PR metadata automation can manage it safely.

Please do one of:

  • Add <!-- meta:issue:123 --> or a normal Closes #123 / Related to #123 line.
  • Check one Workflow Source option in the PR body.
  • Add a hidden marker such as <!-- workflow-source:local_request -->, <!-- workflow-source:manual_remote -->, <!-- workflow-source:review_followup -->, <!-- workflow-source:sync_campaign -->, or <!-- workflow-source:dependabot -->.
  • Add a workflow source label such as workflow:source-direct-pr, workflow:source-local-request, workflow:source-review-followup, workflow:source-sync, or workflow:no-automation.

Once a valid source is present, this warning will not be reposted.

@stranske-keepalive

stranske-keepalive Bot commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🤖 Keepalive Loop Status

PR #3309 | Agent: Codex | Iteration 2/12

Current State

Metric Value
Iteration progress [##--------] 2/12
Action review (progress-review-4)
Gate success
Tasks 0/3 complete
Timeout 45 min (default)
Timeout usage 5m elapsed (12%, 40m remaining)
Keepalive ✅ enabled
Autofix ❌ disabled

🔍 Failure Classification

| Error type | infrastructure |
| Error category | unknown |
| Suggested recovery | Capture logs and context; retry once and escalate if the issue persists. |

@stranske-keepalive

stranske-keepalive Bot commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor
Keepalive Work Log (click to expand)
# Time (UTC) Agent Action Result Files Tasks Progress Commit Gate
0 2026-09-02 04:07:14 Codex wait (gate-pending-transient) skipped 0 0/3
1 2026-09-02 04:10:41 Codex run (bypass-rate-limit-gate) success 32 file(s) 0 0/3 cancelled
2 2026-09-02 04:13:45 Codex run (ready) success 32 file(s) 0 0/3 success
2 2026-09-02 04:20:30 Codex run (agent-run-skipped) skipped 0 0/3 success
2 2026-09-02 04:29:12 Codex wait (gate-pending-transient) skipped 0 0/3
2 2026-09-02 04:33:57 Codex review (progress-review-4) skipped 0 0/3 success

@stranske

stranske commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Validation update for #3306:

  • Remote named check on codex/issue-3306-remove-bootstrap-markers: PASS Workflows (0 bootstrap-path files).
  • Deliberate break/revert: a disposable scratch branch based on this PR head produced FAIL Workflows: 1 after adding agents/codex-1.md, then PASS Workflows (0 bootstrap-path files) after reverting it. The remote and local scratch branch were deleted.
  • pytest tests/workflows/test_issue_bridge_seed.py: 4 passed.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 873726df4f

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread agents/codex-1447.md
@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Runner dispatch state for codex on PR #3309. Do not edit.

Copilot AI left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

🔵 Needs a closer look

It deletes agents/codex-1447.md, which is referenced by and asserted-on in tests/workflows/test_workflow_llm_installs.py and will cause the test to fail unless the fixture is retained or replaced.

Pull request overview

Removes closed/merged “bootstrap marker” files under agents/ as part of the Workflows slice of #3306, leaving only the durable Codex artifacts (e.g., prompt/output) behind.

Changes:

  • Deletes a large set of agents/{codex,auto-pilot,format}-*.md closed/merged bootstrap marker files.
  • Cleans out several legacy needs-human marker/comment files that were tied to closed PRs/issues.
File summaries
File Description
agents/format-580.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-994.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-992.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-989.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-988.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-983.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-982.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-970.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-942.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-936.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-935.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-93.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-922.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-92.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-9.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-895.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-893.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-875.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-8.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-79.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-78.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-77.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-76.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-75.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-74.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-73.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-729.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-725.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-723.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-719.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-693.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-692.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-690.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-582.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-581.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-567.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-545.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-540.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-518.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-483.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-482.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-481.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-480.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-478.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-477.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-457.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-456.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-455.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-454.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-453.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-439.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-405.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-4.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-399.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-397.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-392.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-387.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-380.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-377.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-371.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-368.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-365.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-362.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-359.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-356.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-302.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-299.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-297.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-288.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-287.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-271.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-23.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-213.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-2.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-170.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-17.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-167.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-164.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1638.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-160.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-16.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-157.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-153.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1502.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-15.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1467.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1447.md Deletes a needs-human comment fixture file (currently referenced by tests).
agents/codex-144.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1425.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1419.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1417.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1416.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1407.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1406.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1404.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-14.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1395.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1387.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1385.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1371.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1366.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1365.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1355.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1353.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1342.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1334.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1331.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1322.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-13.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1296.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1279.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1267.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-123.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-12.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-11.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1063.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1039.md Deletes closed marker/comment file.
agents/codex-1038.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1026.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1025.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1021.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1015.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1011.md Deletes closed marker file (contained non-trivial historical content).
agents/codex-101.md Deletes closed marker file.
agents/codex-1006.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1005.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1003.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-1001.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/codex-10.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/auto-pilot-821.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/auto-pilot-785.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/auto-pilot-771.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/auto-pilot-768.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/auto-pilot-763.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
agents/auto-pilot-755.md Deletes closed bootstrap marker file.
Review details
  • Files reviewed: 135/136 changed files
  • Comments generated: 0
  • Review effort level: Lite

💡 Add a code-review agent skill or configure MCP servers for context-aware, tailored reviews. Learn more in the docs.

@stranske
stranske merged commit 1a07fca into main Sep 2, 2026
49 checks passed
@stranske
stranske deleted the codex/issue-3306-remove-bootstrap-markers branch September 2, 2026 04:28
@stranske stranske added the verify:compare Compare multiple LLM evaluations label Sep 2, 2026
@stranske
stranske deployed to agent-high-privilege September 2, 2026 04:28 — with GitHub Actions Active
@stranske-keepalive

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🛑 Progress Review (Round 4)

Recommendation: STOP
Alignment Score: 0.0/10

Feedback

Review your recent work against the acceptance criteria.


This review was triggered because the agent has been working for 4 rounds without completing any task checkboxes.
The review evaluates whether recent work is advancing toward the acceptance criteria.

@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Provider Comparison Report

Provider Summary

Provider Model Verdict Confidence Summary
openai gpt-5.6-terra PASS 87% The change removes the closed/merged bootstrap-path marker files while leaving the two live Codex status files untouched (they are not deleted or modified). The deleted files follow the required `a...
anthropic claude-sonnet-5 PASS 72% This is a low-risk chore PR that bulk-deletes 135 agent bootstrap marker files (agents/-.md) whose corresponding issues/PRs are closed or merged, consistent with the stated task. The...
📋 Full Provider Details (click to expand)

openai

  • Model: gpt-5.6-terra
  • Verdict: PASS
  • Confidence: 87%
  • Scores:
    • Correctness: 9.0/10
    • Completeness: 9.0/10
    • Quality: 8.0/10
    • Testing: 8.0/10
    • Risks: 8.0/10
  • Summary: The change removes the closed/merged bootstrap-path marker files while leaving the two live Codex status files untouched (they are not deleted or modified). The deleted files follow the required agents/<agent>-<number>.md bootstrap-path pattern, supporting the requirement that no such markers remain on the default branch. No production logic is required for the deletion itself, and the existing issue-bridge/path-shape checks are appropriate coverage for this repository-state cleanup. The additional workflow filter is readable and narrowly scoped, though its self-dispatch wording is not fully precise for all workflow-dispatch origins. Overall, the documented cleanup acceptance criteria are satisfied.
  • Concerns:
    • The unrelated optimizer change treats every workflow_dispatch run as a self-dispatched retry. Manually triggered dispatches also match that event type and may contribute to the retry count, so the new comment is slightly broader than the implementation guarantees. This does not affect the bootstrap-marker removal acceptance criteria.

anthropic

  • Model: claude-sonnet-5
  • Verdict: PASS
  • Confidence: 72%
  • Scores:
    • Correctness: 8.0/10
    • Completeness: 7.0/10
    • Quality: 8.0/10
    • Testing: 6.0/10
    • Risks: 8.0/10
  • Summary: This is a low-risk chore PR that bulk-deletes 135 agent bootstrap marker files (agents/-.md) whose corresponding issues/PRs are closed or merged, consistent with the stated task. The two live status files (codex-output.md, codex-prompt.md) are not present in the deletion list, implying they were preserved as required. CI results (pr-00-gate, pr-11-ci-smoke, selftest-ci) all report success, including Python Tests, which plausibly covers the required pytest test_issue_bridge_seed.py suite. The diff also contains a small, seemingly unrelated but harmless tweak to the agents-issue-optimizer.yml workflow (adds an --event filter and clarifying comment) that isn't explicitly part of the stated scope but doesn't appear to introduce risk. Overall the change is straightforward, mechanical, and aligns well with the acceptance criteria, though the verifier cannot fully confirm the PR-body lineage table contents from the provided context.
  • Concerns:
    • The diff includes an unrelated change to .github/workflows/agents-issue-optimizer.yml (adding --event workflow_dispatch filter and a comment) that is not mentioned in the PR's stated scope of removing bootstrap markers. It appears benign and additive, but it represents scope creep not explicitly covered by the acceptance criteria.
    • The verifier cannot independently confirm the PR body lineage table (mapping each deleted file to a CLOSED/MERGED issue/PR) since the full PR description was not included in the provided diff/context — this criterion is taken on faith from the checked checkbox.
    • Cannot directly confirm from the diff alone that 'agents/codex-output.md' and 'agents/codex-prompt.md' were untouched, though their absence from the deletion list is consistent with preservation.
    • No new test file was added specifically to validate 'zero bootstrap files remain' as a repository-level invariant going forward (e.g., a lint/test asserting no agents/-.md pattern exists); reliance is on manual/one-time cleanup rather than an enforced guardrail.

Agreement

  • Verdict: PASS (all providers)
  • Correctness: scores within 1 point (avg 8.5/10, range 8.0-9.0)
  • Quality: scores within 1 point (avg 8.0/10, range 8.0-8.0)
  • Risks: scores within 1 point (avg 8.0/10, range 8.0-8.0)

Disagreement

Dimension openai anthropic
Completeness 9.0/10 7.0/10
Testing 8.0/10 6.0/10

Unique Insights

  • openai: The unrelated optimizer change treats every workflow_dispatch run as a self-dispatched retry. Manually triggered dispatches also match that event type and may contribute to the retry count, so the new comment is slightly broader than the implementation guarantees. This does not affect the bootstrap-marker removal acceptance criteria.
  • anthropic: The diff includes an unrelated change to .github/workflows/agents-issue-optimizer.yml (adding --event workflow_dispatch filter and a comment) that is not mentioned in the PR's stated scope of removing bootstrap markers. It appears benign and additive, but it represents scope creep not explicitly covered by the acceptance criteria.; The verifier cannot independently confirm the PR body lineage table (mapping each deleted file to a CLOSED/MERGED issue/PR) since the full PR description was not included in the provided diff/context — this criterion is taken on faith from the checked checkbox.; Cannot directly confirm from the diff alone that 'agents/codex-output.md' and 'agents/codex-prompt.md' were untouched, though their absence from the deletion list is consistent with preservation.; No new test file was added specifically to validate 'zero bootstrap files remain' as a repository-level invariant going forward (e.g., a lint/test asserting no agents/-.md pattern exists); reliance is on manual/one-time cleanup rather than an enforced guardrail.

🔍 LangSmith Traces

@stranske

stranske commented Sep 2, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Closer verifier disposition

The fresh verify:compare rerun is durable and PASS/PASS: #3309 (comment).

I checked the report's nonblocking scope concerns against the actual PR lineage:

The report's optimizer-workflow statement is therefore a verifier false positive, and the fixture move is bounded completion work required by the deletion. No follow-up debt remains on #3309.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

agents:keepalive Use to initiate keepalive functionality with agents autofix Opt-in automated formatting & lint remediation verify:compare Compare multiple LLM evaluations

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants