fix: add missing fields to native errors in new arch

[vonovak]

Summary:

With 0.74.rc-5 one bug which related to errors was fixed (#41950). However, the fix introduced another one: the shape of Error objects that come from native modules has changed. This PR attempts to fix that, though it's not (yet) doing it in a way that would be 100% compatible with the old arch.

The problem was observed on iOS, not sure what the situation is on Android but believe it's okay there.

edit: on Android, there are no issues but the message field is enumerable, so that part is different from ios (see logs below).

Consider this code, where error is produced from a promise rejection inside of a native module.

console.log('own properties: ',JSON.stringify(Object.getOwnPropertyNames(error),null,2),);console.log('own enumerable properties: ',JSON.stringify(Object.entries(error),null,2),);

These are the results for

Old architecture

 LOG Running "google-one-tap-example" with {"rootTag":1,"initialProps":{}}
LOG own properties: [
"stack",
"code",
"message",
"domain",
"userInfo",
"nativeStackIOS"
]
LOG own enumerable properties: [
[
"code",
"-5"
],
[
"message",
"RNGoogleSignIn: The user canceled the sign in request., Error Domain=com.google.GIDSignIn Code=-5 \"The user canceled the sign-in flow.\" UserInfo={NSLocalizedDescription=The user canceled the sign-in flow.}"
],
[
"domain",
"com.google.GIDSignIn"
],
[
"userInfo",
{
"NSLocalizedDescription": "The user canceled the sign-in flow."
}
],
[
"nativeStackIOS",
[
"0 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102f4a6d8 RCTJSErrorFromCodeMessageAndNSError + 112",
"1 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102eeedd0 __41-[RCTModuleMethod processMethodSignature]_block_invoke_2.73 + 152",
"2 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102e2ae24 +[RNGoogleSignin rejectWithSigninError:withRejector:] + 548",
"3 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102e2aa8c -[RNGoogleSignin handleCompletion:serverAuthCode:withError:withResolver:withRejector:fromCallsite:] + 184",
"4 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102e2a8e0 -[RNGoogleSignin handleCompletion:withError:withResolver:withRejector:fromCallsite:] + 236",
"5 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102e28628 __40-[RNGoogleSignin signIn:resolve:reject:]_block_invoke_2 + 100",
"6 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102dc9d80 __35-[GIDSignIn addCompletionCallback:]_block_invoke_2 + 132",
...
]
]
]

RN 74 rc-5 (with bridgeless on)

 (NOBRIDGE) LOG Bridgeless mode is enabled
(NOBRIDGE) LOG Running "google-one-tap-example" with {"rootTag":1,"initialProps":{"concurrentRoot":true},"fabric":true}
(NOBRIDGE) LOG own properties: [
"stack",
"message",
"cause"
]
(NOBRIDGE) LOG own enumerable properties: [
[
"cause",
{
"code": "-5",
"message": "RNGoogleSignIn: The user canceled the sign in request., Error Domain=com.google.GIDSignIn Code=-5 \"The user canceled the sign-in flow.\" UserInfo={NSLocalizedDescription=The user canceled the sign-in flow.}",
"nativeStackIOS": [
"0 ReactTestApp 0x00000001023a7b38 RCTJSErrorFromCodeMessageAndNSError + 112",
"1 ReactTestApp 0x00000001026cf774 ___ZZN8facebook5react15ObjCTurboModule13createPromiseERNS_3jsi7RuntimeENSt3__112basic_stringIcNS5_11char_traitsIcEENS5_9allocatorIcEEEEU13block_pointerFvU13block_pointerFvP11objc_objectEU13block_pointerFvP8NSStringSH_P7NSErrorEEENK3$_0clES4_RKNS2_5ValueEPSQ_m_block_invoke.57 + 332",
"2 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102270958 +[RNGoogleSignin rejectWithSigninError:withRejector:] + 548",
"3 ReactTestApp 0x00000001022705c0 -[RNGoogleSignin handleCompletion:serverAuthCode:withError:withResolver:withRejector:fromCallsite:] + 184",
"4 ReactTestApp 0x0000000102270414 -[RNGoogleSignin handleCompletion:withError:withResolver:withRejector:fromCallsite:] + 236",
"5 ReactTestApp 0x000000010226e15c __40-[RNGoogleSignin signIn:resolve:reject:]_block_invoke_2 + 100",
"6 ReactTestApp 0x000000010220f328 __35-[GIDSignIn addCompletionCallback:]_block_invoke_2 + 132",
...
],
"domain": "com.google.GIDSignIn",
"userInfo": {
"NSLocalizedDescription": "The user canceled the sign-in flow."
}
}
]
]

with the diff from this PR

 (NOBRIDGE) LOG own properties: [
"stack",
"message",
"code",
"nativeStackIOS",
"domain",
"userInfo"
]
(NOBRIDGE) LOG own enumerable properties: [
[
"code",
"-5"
],
[
"nativeStackIOS",
[
"0 ReactTestApp 0x000000010083b8f8 RCTJSErrorFromCodeMessageAndNSError + 112",
"1 ReactTestApp 0x0000000100b63534 ___ZZN8facebook5react15ObjCTurboModule13createPromiseERNS_3jsi7RuntimeENSt3__112basic_stringIcNS5_11char_traitsIcEENS5_9allocatorIcEEEEU13block_pointerFvU13block_pointerFvP11objc_objectEU13block_pointerFvP8NSStringSH_P7NSErrorEEENK3$_0clES4_RKNS2_5ValueEPSQ_m_block_invoke.57 + 332",
"2 ReactTestApp 0x0000000100704718 +[RNGoogleSignin rejectWithSigninError:withRejector:] + 548",
"3 ReactTestApp 0x0000000100704380 -[RNGoogleSignin handleCompletion:serverAuthCode:withError:withResolver:withRejector:fromCallsite:] + 184",
"4 ReactTestApp 0x00000001007041d4 -[RNGoogleSignin handleCompletion:withError:withResolver:withRejector:fromCallsite:] + 236",
"5 ReactTestApp 0x0000000100701f1c __40-[RNGoogleSignin signIn:resolve:reject:]_block_invoke_2 + 100",
"6 ReactTestApp 0x00000001006a30e8 __35-[GIDSignIn addCompletionCallback:]_block_invoke_2 + 132",
...
]
],
[
"domain",
"com.google.GIDSignIn"
],
[
"userInfo",
{
"NSLocalizedDescription": "The user canceled the sign-in flow."
}
]
]

You see there is a change compared to old arch because message is no longer own enumerable property. If that needs to change (I guess it should), it'd be nice if someone more familiar with JSI pointed me in the right direction. Even with this inconsistency, the PR is an improvement and would be nice to have this fix included in the next RC.

This is output from Chrome's console for completeness, just to have something to compare to:

let err = new Error('hello')
undefined
Object.getOwnPropertyNames(err)
> ['stack', 'message']
Object.entries(err)
> []

Changelog:

Test Plan:

Tested locally with an example app running RN 74-rc 5

[analysis-bot]

Platform	Engine	Arch	Size (bytes)	Diff
android	hermes	arm64-v8a	18,450,670	+1
android	hermes	armeabi-v7a	n/a	--
android	hermes	x86	n/a	--
android	hermes	x86_64	n/a	--
android	jsc	arm64-v8a	21,815,645	-1
android	jsc	armeabi-v7a	n/a	--
android	jsc	x86	n/a	--
android	jsc	x86_64	n/a	--

Base commit: 00725fa
Branch: main

[cortinico]

If you don't mind I'd rather wait for @cipolleschi to review and import this one since he has already context on the previous change. He'll be back next week

[facebook-github-bot]

@cipolleschi has imported this pull request. If you are a Meta employee, you can view this diff on Phabricator.

[cipolleschi]

This change makes sense to me and it basically unwraps the cause object so that errors are the similar in the two architectures.

for:

You see there is a change compared to old arch because message is no longer own enumerable property. If that needs to change (I guess it should), it'd be nice if someone more familiar with JSI pointed me in the right direction.

That goes a little bit out of my experience, so I need to understand better how errors are created... perhaps @RSNara can reply faster than me investigating the source code.

[cipolleschi]

out of curiosity, what happens if we add a line like:

jsError.asObject(runtime).setProperty(runtime, [@"message" UTF8String], convertObjCObjectToJSIValue(runtime, message))

🤔 this might duplicate the message field in the own property (so it should be skipped as there is already another message field), but it should also add the message to the enumerable ones...

[vonovak]

@cipolleschi this is already happening - the for loop iterates over jsErrorDetails, including the message entry

[facebook-github-bot]

@cipolleschi merged this pull request in 98b1331.

[github-actions]

This pull request was successfully merged by @vonovak in 98b1331.

^{When will my fix make it into a release? | How to file a pick request?}