docs(pm): protocol-text family — five graded instruction-face additions, ratchet-paid (wave 4-B)

[claude]

Fixes#11109
Fixes#11083
Fixes#11135
Fixes#11119
Fixes#11298

Governed-surface PR (.claude/**): opened draft and stays draft — human merge only. No seat flips it ready, queues it, or arms auto-merge (Prime Directive 14; ACCEPT-path fork applies).

One graded family, one commit per member, every added line paid by in-place content compression — no ceiling raised, no re-wrap used as payment, no dated ruling or verbatim quote touched.

Per member

• [finding] 「误标不自行改、留言上报」literally instructs the thing another rule forbids — and pm:blocked with no Blocked-by: line is mechanically detectable, so the fix belongs in the patrol not the prose #11109 (wording half) — SKILL.md: both mislabel-report occurrences now state the composed rule 挂 pm:retriage + 异议评论同笔 (多仓协调 4 had 「留言上报」; Guardrails had the variant 「不改标签只上报误标」 — the second occurrence on current main is that variant spelling, verified before editing). Line-count neutral. The patrol-predicate half is wave 4-A's diff (Part of the same card there; not in this PR).
• [finding] The governed-PR review-request notification channel fails for PRs authored by the os-zhuang seat — "Review cannot be requested from pull request author" #11083 (direction 1) — SKILL.md ACCEPT-path clause ③ extended in place: request review where possible; on the author-identity 422 ("Review cannot be requested from pull request author"), assign the PR to os-zhuang instead and say so in the round report. Line-count neutral.
• pm-dispatch finding: queue-entry eligibility is all-checks-green, not required-green (objectui main went red through the queue); per-repo true-green invocations are tribal #11135 — (a) SKILL.md landing funnel: queue-entry eligibility = every check on the PR green, not the required subset; incident distilled without IDs per the id-lint standard (required-green PR queued with a non-required gate red; that repo's main red for about an hour until fix-forward). In-place, line-count neutral. (b) New references/true-green.md: per-repo canonical test invocations, gates invisible to CI-log greps, local preflights — one line per fact. Pointer added in place inside references/review-checklist.md's CI-convergence item (its two-required-jobs floor now explicitly distinguished from the all-checks bar). review-checklist stays at 82/82.
• [finding] Per-commit card trailers get concatenated by the squash — a branch mixing the two trailer spellings lands a self-contradictory commit message, and no authoring doc says so #11119 (cheap version) — .claude/agents/os-dev.md Draft-PR clause: on a branch that will squash, declare the card relation once, in the PR body; keep card-relation trailers out of individual branch commits (the squash concatenates every commit message into one). Paid +2/−2 in the same file: the ablation disk-confirmation double incident narration condensed to its lesson, and one rhetorical elaboration dropped from the gate-exit-code clause. AGENTS.md deliberately untouched: it carries no closing-keyword clause to anchor the sentence and sits at 961/961 headroom 0, so the addition is not ratchet-neutral there — per the graded scope, os-dev.md alone.
• Add the pm:awaiting-maintainer row to the pm-dispatch state model table (deferred fable half of the #11196 landing) #11298 (carries the finding(pm): open+pm:queue+assignee 双向撒谎态,三仓 17 张——四条机器门修法(新 H 规则/配对写入补 assignee/巡查跨仓/H22 窗口),外加一个需裁决的「等人工动作」状态 #11196 ruling) — SKILL.md state-model table: pm:awaiting-maintainer row — meaning (decision made; remaining action is a manual maintainer operation outside GitHub's reach), mutual exclusions (never coexists with pm:queue/pm:dispatched/pm:blocked/pm:on-hold/needs-user-decision), exit (maintainer performs the action; seat clears the label with an evidence comment in the same stroke; no machine exit by construction, carried as parked inventory). Patrol mechanics deliberately not restated — check-half-states.mjs is the enforcement authority (untouched here; wave 4-A owns it). Paid +1/−1: the standby-five list's duplicated parentheticals (each restated authoritatively in its home section) replaced with a pointer 「各项纪律以其主节为准,⛔ 此处不另抄」.

Compression choices (why these were least load-bearing)

Every compressed passage restates a discipline whose authoritative copy lives elsewhere in the same file (standby-list parentheticals ← 发现分诊轮 / 状态模型 / 选择优先级) or narrates an incident twice where once carries the lesson (os-dev ablation narration, gate-exit-code rhetoric). No ruling text, no quote, no mechanism was removed.

Ratchet verdicts (from the post-final-commit union at head 9710e92)

• check-skill-line-ratchet: .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md is 682 lines (ceiling 682; headroom 0).
• check-skill-line-ratchet: .claude/agents/os-dev.md is 405 lines (ceiling 405; headroom 0).
• check-skill-line-ratchet: .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/review-checklist.md is 82 lines (ceiling 82; headroom 0).
• check-skill-line-ratchet: AGENTS.md is 961 lines (ceiling 961; headroom 0). (untouched)

Gates

Derived with node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs (no paths passed; change set from merge-base, provenance line verified: objectstack tree at 9710e92). 11 matched families, all run locally and green at head 9710e92e (verdict lines from the gates' own output, exit captured before any pipe): check:agent-model-declared · check:doc-authoring · lint check:doc-formula-expressions (22 record-scoped examples clean) · check:nul-bytes · check:pm-governed-merges (self-test) · check:pm-governed-prose (2 surfaces name all 5 governed surfaces) · check:pm-skill-id-lint (18 files clean) · check:pm-skill-ratchet (all ceilings hold) · check:required-contexts (6 contexts pinned) · check:skill-frame-sync (4 copies isomorphic — frame copies untouched). First union run predated pnpm install and two gates died on module resolution with a misleading aggregate exit 0 — re-run one-command-per-line under set -e after install + @objectstack/formula build; the final union is the one quoted.

Docs-only .claude/** diff: skip-changeset applied per convention. New page ceiling-row follow-up filed separately: #11310 remains open for triage.

---

Generated by Claude Code